Pat McFadden: All Labour Does is Ask “Who Can We Tax?”

2 min read

Labour cares only about who it can tax in order to pay more in benefits to others, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden complained to Lord Mandelson. The Telegraph has more.

As Sir Keir Starmer’s enforcer in Cabinet, Pat McFadden told the disgraced peer that every meeting he had with members of the Parliamentary Labour Party concerned the question: “Who can we tax in order to pay benefits to others?”

The comments were seized on by the Conservatives, who branded Labour “the welfare party”. 

The frank exchange forms part of the Government’s release of more than 1,500 pages of emails and WhatsApp messages relating to Lord Mandelson’s time as the UK’s ambassador to the US.

The document release on Monday – the largest laid before Parliament since the 2016 Chilcot Inquiry – was demanded by MPs in the wake of Lord Mandelson’s sacking and fresh revelations about his friendship with the convicted paedophile Jeffrey Epstein.

The damning emails and texts paint a picture of a Government at war with itself, led by a Prime Minister lacking the flair to tackle the challenges facing Britain.

Among the explosive exchanges between Lord Mandelson and McFadden were texts sent in the weeks before a major Government climbdown over welfare cuts. 

Last July, No. 10 backed down on £5 billion of cuts to personal independence payments. The climbdown is regarded as the moment Sir Keir ceded power to the soft Left of the parliamentary Labour Party.

McFadden is now the Work and Pensions Secretary, in charge of Britain’s ballooning welfare bill.

Worth reading in full.

Comments

This week across the site:

Email me alerts for this discussion
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to the Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

13 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
JXB
JXB
4 months ago

“The comments were seized on by the Conservatives, who branded Labour “the welfare party”. “

That’s hilarious. Labour created the welfare state in its first term 1945 – 1950.

Has the Conservative Party only just discovered this?

Purpleone
Purpleone
4 months ago
Reply to  JXB

And how do they explain the shambles they were this last 10-15 years, they did bugger all to improve what they inherited, implicitly accepting it as ok…

Gezza England
Gezza England
4 months ago
Reply to  Purpleone

They don’t because as socialists themselves they were continuing the Blairite creed, especially with the loathsome creep Cameron.

JXB
JXB
4 months ago

“Labour cares only about who it can tax in order to pay more in benefits to others…”

It always has! It’s a Socialist cancer which preaches the greed creed: greed, envy, spite – and its modus operandi is to rob selective Peter to pay collective Paul to get votes and stay in power.

Its aim is to destroy a successful capitalist economy by punishing the most productive and rewarding the least productive, transferring wealth from the wealth creators to wealth consumers to disincentivise the former and grow the ranks of the latter until the economy collapses – just about where we are now.

This then “proves” capitalism is a failure and the “answer” is Socialism with its equality, social justice, jam for tea, milk and honey throughout the land.

RTSC
RTSC
4 months ago

I hope McFadden has dug Labour’s grave.

Mrs.Croc
Mrs.Croc
4 months ago

Amazing! He’s only just caught up with what most of us have known since this wretched party came into power!
and he’s supposed to have intelligent?

soundofreason
soundofreason
4 months ago

From the full article:

A spokesman for Mr McFadden said: “Pat has said publicly many times that the question we should ask is not what are you entitled to, but how can we change your life?

Why the Hell does he want to change people’s lives? What gives him the moral authority to decide that other people’s lives should be different to how they are?

Elsewhere he’s quoted as saying:

They’re asking the wrong questions.

He’s starting from the wrong assumption. It’s not government’s job to change people – nor to replace them.

GroundhogDayAgain
GroundhogDayAgain
4 months ago
Reply to  soundofreason

Change your own life. Strive. Take risks. Succeed.

vs

My government gives me nice things.

soundofreason
soundofreason
4 months ago

vs My government tries to prevent me succeeding.

MajorMajor
MajorMajor
4 months ago

Pat McFadden: All Labour Does is Ask “Who Can We Tax?”
Yes, that about sums up Labour’s economic policy.

And what makes it worse is that the result of these extra taxes: nothing, nada, zilch. More people in poverty, more food banks, crumbling infrastructure, more bureaucracy, more unemployment, more welfare dependency.

RTSC
RTSC
4 months ago
Reply to  MajorMajor

Just like the Soviet Union.

Hester
Hester
4 months ago
Reply to  RTSC

“In order to create a new world, we must first destroy the old one”. That is precisely what they are doing.

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
4 months ago

Ah that has made my evening!

Thank you for reading. Please help us keep the Daily Sceptic going by becoming a donor.