Premium

The Guardian Journalist Who Targeted the Free Speech Union is a “Senior Tarbell Fellow”. What Does That Mean?

The Guardian journalist who targeted the Free Speech Union with a story stuffed with misinformation, Aisha Down, is a "Senior Tarbell Fellow". Charlotte Gill investigates what that means.

3 min read

As many Daily Sceptic readers will know, the Free Speech Union was recently a victim of misinformation at the hands of the Guardian. In a piece published last Friday, the paper claimed that the Trump administration was to grant $12 million to “groups founded by UK conservatives Jacob Rees-Mogg and Toby Young”.

Ahead of its publication, Toby refuted the claims to be made in the piece, put to him in an email by a journalist called Aisha Down. It’s worth reading this piece to get all the details.

I was curious to see Down sign off in her emails as a “Senior Tarbell Fellow”. What on earth is that, I wondered. Although it’s not the main takeaway of the story, it’s certainly an interesting rabbit hole – showing how many players there are now in journalism.

Down’s fellowship is with something called “The Tarbell Center for AI Journalism”, as you can see from her Guardian profile here...

…as well as the Tarbell Centre’s own website:

The Tarbell Centre is named in honour of Ida Tarbell, “best known for writing The History of the Standard Oil Company”:

However, The Tarbell Center for AI Journalism (unsurprisingly) focuses on AI, and says it “supports journalism that helps navigate the emergence of advanced AI”.

Accordingly, its fellowship is a “one-year programme for journalists interested in covering artificial intelligence”, something Aisha Down didn’t touch upon in her piece about Toby and Jacob Rees-Mogg, incidentally. The Tarbell Centre is still keen to show the

Keep reading –
Donate £5 monthly
or £50 annually

Subscribe today to get unlimited online access, as well as our Premium newsletters and podcasts.

  • Read paywalled articles
  • Comment below the line and connect with other users
  • Watch and listen to the longer Premium version of our weekly podcast
  • Listen to every article
  • Receive Premium version of our daily newsletter
DONATE NOW

Comments

This week across the site:

Email me alerts for this discussion
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to the Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

21 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Mrs.Croc
Mrs.Croc
1 month ago

Why are all these so called journalists young women of a certain type?

JohnCaldigate
JohnCaldigate
1 month ago

Down’s syndrome?

Corky Ringspot
Corky Ringspot
1 month ago

KUTGW, Charlotte. (Keep up the good etc)

marebobowl
marebobowl
1 month ago

Preparation of the next generation of msm stooges. Avoid. Turn off all msm media, do not read, listen to or watch msm. It continues to spew misinformation to the sheep.

Matt Dalby
Matt Dalby
2 months ago

She sounds like a Senior Tarbell end Fellow.

Willsywoo44
Willsywoo44
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Dalby

👏👏👏

Mrs.Croc
Mrs.Croc
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Dalby

🤣🤣🤣🤣😘🤣🤣🤣🤣
congratulations, we knew it was going to come!

Cotfordtags
Cotfordtags
2 months ago

The deceitful socialists that are found feeding off the largesse of all of these donors have a new expression now. While knowingly peddling their lies, they know that many, such as those of us here, are actually telling the truth and they cannot refute the truth. They are now talking about malinformation, that is inconvenient truth that they would rather is not shared amongst the public. Only their version of the world is allowed.

Tonka Rigger
Tonka Rigger
2 months ago

They don’t bite the hand that feeds them, and will churn out endless ideologically-driven tripe as long as the cash comes in. More fool those that pay for it.

Howard Arnaud
Howard Arnaud
2 months ago

All a bit bizarre.

There’s nothing in the Guardian article about AI, so it looks like she’s gone off piste here.

If that’s what working for the Guardian does to its journalists, just think what it does to its readers.

stewart
stewart
2 months ago
Reply to  Howard Arnaud

In case anyone is wondering why mad, progressive narratives never go away despite their being at odds with observable reality:

Screenshot-2026-07-25-at-11.08.43
WillP
WillP
2 months ago

As newspapers loose readers and revenue, creep houses like this see an advantage. I’m guessing they found the placement.

one of the most shocking careers is that of raving antisemite and Muslim Brother hood fan boy, Mahdi Hussane. PPE at Oxford, (obvs) then ITV, BBC, C4, AlJazeera, Guardian, Huff Post… a check list of Brit loathing political activism employers. I’m sure the fact he was Muslim gave him no employment advantage with this lot. He even has an award from ‘Friends of Europe’

JeremyP99
JeremyP99
2 months ago
Reply to  WillP

Lose NOT Loose. Loose means release.

Alec in France
Alec in France
1 month ago
Reply to  JeremyP99

Or slack.

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
2 months ago

Surely the FSU article was disinformation (or lying as it used to be called) not misinformation, as the “journalist” ignored what TY wrote and went ahead with the article knowing it was false.

NickR
NickR
2 months ago

This is the odd thing. The FSU use the courts to seek redress for its members. They win almost all of their cases, demonstrating that their client was treated illegally.
It seems odd, that attempting to uphold the law is regarded as ‘hateful’.

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
2 months ago
Reply to  NickR

Socialists and wokesters hate free speech. It threatens them.

Hound of Heaven
Hound of Heaven
2 months ago

They have an aversion to the truth.

DiscoveredJoys
DiscoveredJoys
2 months ago

Perhaps we should launch a new phrase to earmark such activities – misjournalism.

Similar articles don’t write themselves, but I wouldn’t compromise my ideals by censoring them. I would just dismissively brand them as false with the one word, misjournalism. We used to assume that journalists could be mistaken, but now it appears that a degree of idealistic intention is creeping in.

Hound of Heaven
Hound of Heaven
2 months ago

Surely, nothing written by a journalist funded by and beholden to shadowy globalists will be objective or worth reading. Great research Charlotte Gill.

Gezza England
Gezza England
1 month ago

And certainly not when published in the Guardian. And note her Far Left Bluesky account link.

Thank you for reading. Please help us keep the Daily Sceptic going by becoming a donor.