Premium

Will Miatta Fahnbulleh Be as Mad as Ed Miliband?

Ed Miliband has been replaced at the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero by unknown junior minister Miatta Fahnbulleh. Is this a sign of the demotion of climate alarmism or continuity madness, asks Ben Pile.

6 min read

Though he spent four and a half years as leader of the Labour Party, Ed Miliband, formerly secretary of state for energy security and Net Zero, is synonymous with climate policy. His characteristic zeal was evident for the 20 months he served as the first secretary of state for energy and climate change in the dying days of Gordon Brown’s government. But following Andy Burnham’s coronation, Miliband has been appointed to the Foreign Office, and replaced at DESNZ by a relatively unknown junior minister, Miatta Fahnbulleh. So what does this game of musical chairs signify? What does it mean for Britain’s mad Net Zero agenda?

It’s been clear since the General Election that something was going to give. Many, including me, didn’t think that Miliband and his brand of Net Zero would last this long. But the dam broke upstream of DESNZ and Ed. Early rumours suggested that Miliband would give the top job another go and was among the favourites to occupy Number 10. But, having ruled himself out, and as the concept of democratic contest drained from the question of the party’s leadership, Miliband was being touted as a possible fit for Number 11. It would be harder to say if Miliband hadn’t been such a zealot, but there is clearly some significance to his move away from climate and energy. Whereas a role such as Chancellor of the Exchequer would have left him able to advance his green-Left agenda, as Foreign Secretary, domestic affairs are somewhat

Keep reading –
Donate £5 monthly
or £50 annually

Subscribe today to get unlimited online access, as well as our premium newsletters and podcasts.

  • Read paywalled articles
  • Comment below the line and connect with other users
  • Watch and listen to the premium version of our weekly podcast
  • Listen to every article
  • Receive premium version of our daily newsletter
DONATE NOW

Comments

This week across the site:

Email me alerts for this discussion
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to the Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

49 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Old Brit
Old Brit
1 month ago

As usual, no science qualification, just PPE and Greenomics. An interview with Katherine Porter would be interesting

MrVeryAngry
MrVeryAngry
1 month ago

She is simply certifiable. A key member of the cretinocracy.

sarah
sarah
1 month ago

Why didn’t Iain Dale point out that UK would only make 1% of a difference to so called global emissions if we reach the mythical net zero? She sounded like she believes our 1% will save the world

Sarony
Sarony
1 month ago

The portfolio may be a poisoned chalice, but there are some who thrive on poison.

V Detta
V Detta
1 month ago

See Charlotte Gill’s articles on MF here – she has been trained by a Soros funded organisation to speak about this rubbish (“Climate change is the biggest threat since Brexit”). https://www.charlottecgill.co.uk/p/every-article-you-need-to-understand?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Covid-1984
Covid-1984
1 month ago

She couldn’t even find her way out of Downing Street. What chance have we got?🙄

Zipp0
Zipp0
1 month ago

Section them

Hardliner
1 month ago

I’m hugely disappointed to see Wallace leave his exalted post at Energy and head off to the Private Jets of the Foreign Office before he has handed out the £300 that he promised us off our energy bills? Any progress on that, Wallace?

I assume that flying by PJ will miraculously become carbon-neutral overnight, as it did for that odious loser Harry Wales? Or will taxpayers be buying trees in Brazil on your behalf Ed? I think we should be told

Heretic
Heretic
1 month ago
Reply to  Hardliner

Wow, you are right! He really does often look like Wallace of “Wallace & Gromit!”
Except Nick Park’s Wallace is better looking.
So is Gromit
and the penguin…
🙂

JXB
JXB
1 month ago

Ed Milibland is a psychopath. Fatootanoola is just a mindless blob. No less dangerous of course.

Gezza England
Gezza England
1 month ago

Sounds like a good plan to appoint a nobody like Fattybullah to the job just as it really begins to unravel. We know that Mad Ed’s plan had failed from Minute One and as we get closer to not having enough reliable generation hard decisions have to be made so having a nonentity means they can be brushed aside in a way Mad Ed couldn’t. But then so much of government comes as an unexpected outcome because they are unable to plan.

Western Firebrand
Western Firebrand
1 month ago

Seems to have been raised with the belief that the solution to every woe is other peoples’ money (a bit like her predecessor, but more so).

soundofreason
soundofreason
1 month ago

Miliband wouldn’t want to be in DESNZ when the first major power outage occurs. As long as the grid stays up until Winter he can probably convince far too many people to blame Fahnbulleh when it does happen.

shred
shred
1 month ago
Reply to  soundofreason

David Turver on his Eigenvalues site has an article on the NESO grid, which used to be run by National Grid and has been taken over by government, has been embarrassed by engineer whistle-blowers telling Clair Courtino that the system is dangerously near collapse because of lack of spinning reserves, as in Iberia. The management of course have denied everything and attacked the messenger for damaging the company. The article identifies 7 ways in which standards have been fiddled to a dangerous level of reserves.

Hardliner
1 month ago
Reply to  shred

Turver’s articles are dry and technical but worth every minute of reading them. He’s a grown up

Matt Dalby
Matt Dalby
1 month ago

How long before she says climate change is due to colonialism, toxic masculinity, is evidence of systemic racism or due to some other chip on her shoulder?

Sarony
Sarony
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Dalby

Five minutes.

Matt Dalby
Matt Dalby
1 month ago

Lammy’s gone so there has to be a new token black in the cabinet. Mahmood’s the token Muslim, Streeting the token gay, Burnham just needs to find a neurodiverse person and someone disabled to complete the set and bang on about the cabinet being the most diverse it’s ever been.

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Dalby

Burnham’s the token Supermarionation puppet – Joe 90 with dark hair. The glasses used to transfer knowledge to Joe via the BIG RAT have been programmed by the WEF, he is operating with Klaus Schwab’s brainwaves inside him.

Douglas Brodie
Douglas Brodie
1 month ago

The LBC interview indicates that Fahnbulleh is a “useful idiot” for the deep state who has swallowed the establishment’s false climate change propaganda hook, line and sinker. There is no point in trying to make her see sense. The real imperative is to mobilise against the deep state – don’t ask me how – which is determined to ruin the country via Net Zero and other oppressions.

huxleypiggles
huxleypiggles
1 month ago
Reply to  Douglas Brodie

“other oppressions” principally being population replacement.

Rose Madder
Rose Madder
1 month ago

“deliver the ‘just transition’”

a) it is possible and desirable to think rationally about how society should be arranged;
b) this ought to be done to make it distributively just.

Rawls wot did it

I read that here once – it’s the wouldn’t-it-be-nice mind rot that underpins our current system trouble, said man. McGrogan? Would appreciate a follow up.

JohnK
JohnK
1 month ago

Doesn’t it depend on how skilled the Permanent Secretary is at indoctrination?

LadbrokeGrove
LadbrokeGrove
1 month ago

The IPCC having admitted that the assumptions used in the standard climate ‘forecasts’ are rubbish, has anyone seen a ‘forecast’ using plausible assumptions?

Boomer Bloke
Boomer Bloke
1 month ago

Perhaps they could start by decarbonising her, that would demonstrate very clearly the importance of carbon for life on Earth.

Hardliner
1 month ago
Reply to  Boomer Bloke

Notice that neither she nor Mad Ed have the letter C in their names – already decarbonised!
I wonder how she got on in her STEM subjects at school? One thing that really troubled me about Mad Ed is that he had the education to understand the science and engineering of Net Zero, but still ploughed on spouting crap for years. No evidence that Fandango has the first clue about STEM

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
1 month ago

Miliband was broadly speaking just carrying on the policies agreed to by all but 5 MPs and carried on by the Fake Conservative government for 14 years.

shred
shred
1 month ago

She’s had the best education in Britain and is therefore completely deluded. Expect a commitment to vastly increase government investment in wind, solar, carbon capture, insulation and heat pumps,.grid replacement, hydrogen hubs- and a further collapse of manufacturing and an increase in CGT and inheritance tax, with bankruptcy all round.

RTSC
RTSC
1 month ago

Father Liberian, mother from Sierra Leone. The family came here and claimed asylum in the mid-80s. She’s obviously “as British as you and me” …. just like Badenough.

I suspect she will want to enthusiastically implement the UN’s Climate Agenda, which they admitted many years ago has nothing to do with the climate and was actually about transferring wealth from the “undeserving west” to Africa and Asia.

https://www.climatedepot.com/2017/05/24/global-warming-is-not-about-the-science-un-admits-climate-change-policy-is-about-how-we-redistribute-the-worlds-wealth/

Hound of Heaven
Hound of Heaven
1 month ago
Reply to  RTSC

That’s right. No one need look any further than the UN Agendas 2030 and 2050 to which the UK is a signatory and about which there is relative silence.

huxleypiggles
huxleypiggles
1 month ago
Reply to  RTSC

The “climate change” nonsense emanates from the Club of Rome (1972) and its purpose was total control of the planet, it’s people and resources.

Heretic
Heretic
1 month ago
Reply to  RTSC

Yes, I’ve just been looking into her family’s background in Africa, and she’s from a long line of Leftards on both sides. Her name “Miatta” is from the dominant Mende Tribe of Sierra Leone who keep the other tribes firmly underfoot, sandals planted on their necks, and have all sorts of voodoo ritual tribal beliefs; her brother’s name “Gamal” is Muslim; her father was a Liberian Foreign Minister; and she, like Olukemi Olufunto to whom she bears a remarkable resemblance, having a similar Bloated Sense of Entitlement, will bring all sorts of Marxist African Political Craziness and Tribal Conflicts to Britain, just as the Hindus & Muslims & Sikhs bring their own conflicts here. All that’s missing is Argentinians fighting Venezuelans in the streets. The benefits of DEI that nobody ever voted for…

It is appalling that “friendly Andy” Burnham may also end up with this African Marxist Harpy’s sandal planted firmly on his neck, and British voters will end up with a choice between two Ethnic African women for UK Prime Minister, an Ethnic African woman as “Queen Regent” for Illegitimate Surrogate Sprogs with no right to the throne, Muslims flying the Black Flag of Islam over Parliament, every… Read more »

Covid-1984
Covid-1984
1 month ago
Reply to  RTSC

Badenoch is an anchor baby dumped on us by her fleeing mother.

Sarony
Sarony
1 month ago
Reply to  RTSC

Burnham has looked across the floor and thought ‘ooh-er, must elevate an ethnic woman to show Labour is as committed to DEI-ism as the evil Tories.’

For a fist full of roubles
For a fist full of roubles
1 month ago

We have been told for nearly 30 years that we have 10 years to take action. What more proof do you need that their motives are not to save the planet, but to enhance their power over us.

Claphamanian
Claphamanian
1 month ago

Or is the replacement of Miliband with this lady the same sort of switch that was made when Starmer was replaced with Burnham? The cause had become tarnished by a too long association with one name. In the lady’s case, her political anonymity is a ‘circuit breaker’ to the current of criticism.

Is it really likely that the regime is going to give up on Net Zero and carbon-free?

Arum
Arum
1 month ago
Reply to  Claphamanian

seems very unlikely – but someone has to be holding the parcel when the music stops, and we won’t have to wait until 2050 for that to happen I think.

Jack the dog
Jack the dog
1 month ago
Reply to  Arum

That interview is pretty scary stuff – people as thick, deluded and misinformed should be nowhere near the “levers of power”.

She’s obviously done the Kamala Harris correspondence course of assembling word salad.

It’s Alice in WOnderland stuff, and not in a good way.

mrbu
mrbu
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack the dog

She wants an “economy that works for people”. How does a wrecked economy and national bankruptcy “work for people”? It threatens livelihoods, health, social mobility, social cohesion. History has proved that the only kind of economy that really works for people is based on plentiful supplies of cheap energy, and that’s something we could have. It takes the political will not, as she thinks, to push Net Zero harder, but to take a step back, admit we’ve been on the wrong path, and get back to the basics.

Jack the dog
Jack the dog
1 month ago
Reply to  mrbu

Because these people are without exception creatures of the blob, and have never had to make anything real, work and have always existed in an ideological echo chamber, they are utterly devoid of the basic skills of management.

They do not understand that there no solutions only trade-offs and seem to be totally lacking in any moral or intellectual hinterland.

They are without exception unfit for the highest offices of state, and that sorry situation is likely to cost us our livelihoods, our country and indeed our civilization.

Zipp0
Zipp0
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack the dog

💯

Zipp0
Zipp0
1 month ago
Reply to  mrbu

Bonkers of course

Sarony
Sarony
1 month ago
Reply to  mrbu

Show me a politician who admits they were wrong.

GasBoy75
GasBoy75
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack the dog

Well done Jack, for having a strong enough constitution to watch & listen to this lady. I’m guessing you waited ‘til your lunch had been fully digested.
I have heard her speak several times on the radio, and each time I’m left with the feeling that she’s not quite the full ticket. She appears to have the knack of saying absolutely nothing, very confidently.

Purpleone
Purpleone
1 month ago
Reply to  GasBoy75

She’ll go far with this bunch of shysters then, won’t she…

Heretic
Heretic
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack the dog

She’s obviously done the Kamala Harris correspondence course of assembling word salad.”
😂

Zipp0
Zipp0
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack the dog

Thick as mince

Hound of Heaven
Hound of Heaven
1 month ago
Reply to  Zipp0

Except she’s there and we’re here. That makes us stupid.

Thank you for reading. Please help us keep the Daily Sceptic going by becoming a donor.