Premium

BBC Claims Monsoon is ‘Too Wet’ – Two Years After Saying it Was ‘Drying Up’ Due to Climate Change

The BBC has claimed that India's monsoon this year is 'too wet' – two years after saying it was 'drying up' due to climate change. Make up your mind, says Paul Homewood. In fact, data show the monsoons remain normal.

3 min read

India’s summer monsoon is without doubt the single major event of the year for the country. A wet summer leads to increased food production, in turn boosting rural incomes.

India’s economy is still heavily dependent on agriculture, which accounts for a fifth of GDP and nearly half of the workforce. A good harvest therefore increases spending power in the wider economy and lowers food prices. On top of that, rainfall fills up the dams, boosting hydro electricity generation. In short, it generates economic growth and boosts the stock market.

It has therefore come as good news that this year’s monsoon, which runs from the beginning of June to the end of September, brought 8% more rain than normal for the second year running.

Rice production is expected to increase 6.6% compared to last year, as rainfall has allowed a greater area to be sown. Wheat harvests are also projected to go up by 2.8% from last year’s already record outputs.

Contrary to the misinformation put out by the BBC a couple of years ago, India’s monsoons have not been drying up. On the contrary, droughts were much more severe in the 1960s to 80s when global temperatures were dropping.

The chart below from Monsoon Online runs to 2023, but I have updated it to this year in the graph below it:

Indian meteorologists generally define drought as a rainfall deficit of 10% or more; the next chart plots these drought years. Since 2010, there have only been two

Keep reading –
Donate £5 monthly
or £50 annually

Subscribe today to get unlimited online access, as well as our Premium newsletters and podcasts.

  • Read paywalled articles
  • Comment below the line and connect with other users
  • Watch and listen to the longer Premium version of our weekly podcast
  • Listen to every article
  • Receive Premium version of our daily newsletter
DONATE NOW

Comments

This week across the site:

Email me alerts for this discussion
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to the Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

11 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Spiv
Spiv
11 months ago

Climate activists are using weather fluctuations in either direction. It is human arrogance to assume that our pointless little activities can change the ecosphere of the planet.
Pollution is ours, we need to own it and fix it, but the hysterical nonsense about carbon is ridiculous.

ELH
ELH
11 months ago
Reply to  Spiv

Yes exactly.

The other point is the Hunga Tonga underwater volcanic eruption of 15.01.2022 which put 13% more water vapour into the stratosphere. That which goes up will come down in good time.

marebobowl
marebobowl
11 months ago

There is no doubt the world is experiencing weather manipulation. No one can deny the chem trails, day after day, being spread by aircraft. Professor Willie Soon, an astrophysicist is a good resource for climate science data. Why anyone would use the bbc for anything other than stories about movie stars and royalty, is does not make sense.

David Jones
David Jones
11 months ago

Political Thinking with Nick Robinson and Claire Coutinho
18th Oct, on BBC Radio 4.The topic was Climate, Identity and Cooking.

Nick suggested that the abandonment of net zero could be seen as some sort of existential threat to humanity. Claire gave an adequate repost in the time available before the discussion turned to identity. 
I didn’t listen to the rest of the broadcast as I couldn’t fathom out how the abolition of the Net Zero policy which, if pursued (according to Nick), could endanger our very existence, was given such a cursory examination. Unless, of course, it was intended to dilute Claire’s message and distract the listeners from the existential threat of the Net Zero policy.

Western Firebrand
Western Firebrand
11 months ago

I remember a National Geographic cover photo of an Indian tailor carrying his sewing machine while crossing a monsoon-swollen river up to his neck. That was probably some forty years ago. I suspect the BBC “researchers” can only draw upon much fewer years of experience, such that every year is “unprecedented”.

Westfieldmike
Westfieldmike
11 months ago

Surely nobody takes any notice of the unhinged BBC?

mickie
mickie
11 months ago

Water is wet yet again.

RW
RW
11 months ago

India has a population of 1.451 billion people. 1500 of 1.451 billion people dying is a non-event, regardless of the cause. That’s only 5.5% of the number of people which die in India every day.

Art Simtotic
Art Simtotic
11 months ago

As Professor Humlum’s scholarly analysis shows year after year…

https://thegwpf.org/content/uploads/2025/10/The-State-of-the-Climate-2024.pdf

“…Believing that one minor constituent of the atmosphere (CO₂) controls nearly all aspects of climate is amazingly naïve and entirely unrealistic.

…There is no observational evidence for any global climate crisis.

…Our world should consider focussing on much more pressing problems.”

Monro
Monro
11 months ago
Reply to  Art Simtotic

Great reference. Thanks.

Jack the dog
Jack the dog
11 months ago

Defunding the BBC is probably the most important task for reform after they win the next election, perhaps after lunch on day 1 having stopped the boats in the morning – task anybody here could achieve in a morning. We know what they need to do.

Thank you for reading. Please help us keep the Daily Sceptic going by becoming a donor.