Premium

I Smell a Rat in the BBC’s Claims of Climate Change ‘Ratmageddon’

Rodent populations in the US and Britain have exploded, and the BBC inevitably blames climate change. But Ben Pile smells a rat. After all, there are much more likely explanations than slightly milder weather.

7 min read

There is nothing that a BBC 'journalist' will not try to turn into a story about climate change. Last week, it was the story of rats – Ratmageddon, according to BBC News Climate Editor Justin Rowlatt, is upon us. In Britain and the USA, rat populations have increased. And since global warming has destroyed the rat’s main enemy – cold – it is very obviously anthropogenic climate change that is responsible for the rodent’s population explosion.

I, erm, smell a rat though. Isn’t it odd that we hear so much about mankind’s impact on the natural world, and especially on animal populations, yet the urban rat is thriving? The Living Planet Index – a fictional metric of the world’s wildlife population – for example claims that 70% of wildlife has disappeared since 1970. What a pity that the humble sewer rat is not on such a path to extinction, it being one of so few creatures to have developed the capacity to adapt to very slightly different weather and urban expansion.

“Researchers say,” says Rowlatt, “[rat] numbers are particularly prone to increase in cities.” “That's because their heat-trapping tarmac and buildings tend to warm more quickly than rural areas.” One such “researcher” is a self-styled “urban rodentologist” Dr Bobby Corrigan – a former exterminator in New York. "Land is disappearing like crazy, and we're putting up buildings so we reduce their [rats] habitat in the wild," claims Corrigan, whose 'research' also finds that “cities experiencing greater temperature increases over time saw larger increases in

Keep reading –
Donate £5 monthly
or £50 annually

Subscribe today to get unlimited online access, as well as our Premium newsletters and podcasts.

  • Read paywalled articles
  • Comment below the line and connect with other users
  • Watch and listen to the longer Premium version of our weekly podcast
  • Listen to every article
  • Receive Premium version of our daily newsletter
DONATE NOW

Comments

This week across the site:

Email me alerts for this discussion
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to the Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

18 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
NubOfTheMatter
NubOfTheMatter
11 months ago

But, surely, rats must feature in the BBC supported re-wilding programme? Come now!

Western Firebrand
Western Firebrand
11 months ago

Well at least these are the brown or Norwegian rats – not the black or ship rats that carried the plague and arrived in Britain as illegal migrants…

sskinner
sskinner
11 months ago

And the plague happened during the Little Ice Age.

RocketRon
RocketRon
11 months ago

Rowlatt is a feeble toady to the WEF agenda, gets fired up about every aspect of the narrative.
Rowland Rat would be more convincing.

lulu-b45
lulu-b45
11 months ago

How does anyone know if every rat filled in the ratcensus form last time… and this time? Maybe they’re just more obvious

DiscoveredJoys
DiscoveredJoys
11 months ago

Wouldn’t it be a hoot if the primary way of controlling urban rat populations was found to be replacing refuse bags with proper bins and increasing the frequency of rubbish collections? Providing more litter bins, plus making littering a much more serious offence?

It would, of course, increase costs and therefore taxes but how much does ‘Ratmageddon’ cost?

Much like the increase in fly-tipping goes hand in hand with the increased difficulty of throwing stuff away.

john1T
john1T
11 months ago

There are many immigrant districts around my local town of Rotherham. One such is Eastwood. You would not believe the amount of rubbish and junk these people leave outside their houses in their front gardens. It’s a rat’s paradise.

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
11 months ago
Reply to  john1T

Same where I used to live in London.

john1T
john1T
11 months ago

I’m far more concerned by the rodents running the government.

psychedelia smith
psychedelia smith
11 months ago

Does climate change also make the council not collect you bin regularly anymore?

Mrs Bunty
Mrs Bunty
11 months ago

“Researchers say,” says Rowlatt, “[rat] numbers are particularly prone to increase in cities.” “That’s because their heat-trapping tarmac and buildings tend to warm more quickly than rural areas.”

Wow, they admit that it gets warmer in towns and cities where there is tarmac and concrete. Maybe that has something to do with higher temperatures they’re recording? Numbskulls. They can’t work out that a temperature recording device on an airport runway might give a high recording?

ElaineH
ElaineH
11 months ago

I smell a rat. Like a religious climate zealot.

RTSC
RTSC
11 months ago

Wouldn’t it be interesting if someone did a study to determine the correlation between the opening of fast food premises and the effect on the local rat population.

If you put out food, you attract rats. As anyone who feeds “the birds” … or hedgehogs come to that … should know.

transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
11 months ago
Reply to  RTSC

Back in my London days, our borough sponsored an initiative to reduce litter. They were looking for useful low cost suggestions – I guess usual stuff along the lines of “get kids to paint nice pictures with ‘please don’t litter'” written on them. I said they should shut down some of the fried chicken shops. It didn’t seem to get taken up.

jclea3
jclea3
11 months ago

Would chuck into the mix food recycling bins, most mornings on bin day there is one opened up with food on the street.

JohnK
JohnK
11 months ago

And don’t forget about utility firms, in particular the water companies that own common sewers, like Thames Water. No shortage of rats in those, as many know.

Arum
Arum
11 months ago

Another factor that might be relevant is resistance to rodenticides.

Gezza England
Gezza England
11 months ago
Reply to  Arum

And the banning of effective ones or introducing a licencing regime so onerous it becomes uneconomic to make it.

Thank you for reading. Please help us keep the Daily Sceptic going by becoming a donor.