I thought it was just me, but it transpires there are fewer Christmas decorations in Hong Kong this year than in previous years. A colleague confirmed, under orders from China, Hong Kong had been instructed to tone down the outward manifestations of the Christmas festivities this year.
I often find myself in Hong Kong in the run up to Christmas and in years gone past, the Christmas light show on both sides of the harbour, but especially on the island side has been dazzling. All the major buildings in Hong Kong are festooned with lights which can be programmed to convey seasonal images such as on the Chinese New Year and at Christmas. The lights are always spectacular, but at Christmas we have been treated to Father Christmas climbing up vast towers and even appearing to jump between buildings on the island side. Reindeer float from building to building and, while not ostensibly Christian, it is as Christmassy as Santa’s grotto.
Let there be (fewer) lights
On the Kowloon side, where there are not many truly high-rise buildings, the ICC (International Commercial Centre) which houses some major financial institutions and the Ritz Carlton hotel with its spectacular Ozone bar, the highest bar in the word at 480 metres, dominates. Normally it provides a good show at this time of year but on a visit to Ozone this week I looked up to see, well, nothing much. Looking across the island from Ozone, the light show was as usual but barely Christmas themed at all.
My colleague, who had just returned from mainland China also said that the authorities in China had banned Christmas celebrations this year. I tried to confirm this with a mainland colleague, a Chinese social media influencer. Using a carefully chosen series of emojis on WeChat to avoid detection by a Sinobot and getting him into trouble he said that it did not appear to be the case as, in his words, “Shanghai has loads of Christmas vibes”.
Santa (but with clauses)
Google turned up an article in Asia Media Centre titled ‘Even Santa is political – China’s battle over festivals’. It transpires, while the central Government has not banned Christmas this year in China, certain provincial governments are clamping down. The problem for the Chinese authorities at central and provincial levels is, despite China being officially an atheist state, Chinese people love Christmas. Even more than the people, businesses love Christmas as, among the many festivals and holidays at which China excels, Christmas offers yet another reason to sell goods. It seems that the worship of mammon really has replaced the worship of God.
Of course, there are Christians in China and, occasionally, I meet some. They never declare their faith in a large group. Wherever two or three are gathered together in China, you can rest assured that one of them will be a member of the Chinese Communist Party. But now and then I’ll be asked on an individual basis if I am a Christian, which I am, and they will tell me about their faith. And their struggles.
There are churches in mainland China and many universities such as Peking Union Medical College were established in pre-Communist times by missionaries. The surviving churches, marked by large red fluorescent light crosses (until now, more of which later), usually belong to American evangelical groups such as the Church of Christ, also active in Taiwan and Thailand. Seventh Day Adventists also function here; they run the prestigious Sir Run Run Shaw private hospital in Hangzhou.
Religious rites (are wrong)
Presumably, these denominations have agreed to comply with the restrictions placed on them by the Chinese Government. Essentially, their activities need to be controlled by the Government, and they are prohibited from proselytising. Such restrictions long prevented the Roman Catholic Church – the one in Communion with Rome – from operating other than underground in China. Rome traditionally refused to comply with the Chinese insistence that they should have a say in the appointment of clergy.
However, much to the anger of former Hong Kong Roman Catholic Cardinal Joseph Zen, Rome reached an agreement with the Chinese Government, recently extended, whereby Rome would continue to select bishops in China but that their appointments would have to be approved by the Government. Cardinal Zen’s outspokenness has, periodically, landed him in prison in Hong Kong. To the consternation of many Roman Catholics – your correspondent included – the agreement was renewed despite a reported violation by the Chinese Government when China appointed a bishop in Shanghai without reference to the Vatican.
Concerns about Christmas in China and in its special administrative region of Hong Kong naturally raise concerns about the survival of Christianity and Christians in China. Before long, Hong Kong will effectively be China, as the border and the full force of Chinese law extends to include the current Hong Kong border. The Roman Catholic Church, which thrives in Hong Kong, is of particular concern mainly due to its allegiance to Rome.
I went to a vigil mass in a huge modern church in the New Territories of Hong Kong on Saturday and it was standing room only for late arrivals. I have been to the same church on a Sunday morning, and it is similarly packed. Catholic Churches in the U.K. can only dream of such congregations.
Oh bug(ger)
All the signs are that China is beginning to clamp down even further than it has traditionally done. This year the Chinese Government ordered the removal of crosses from churches and the replacement of sacred images – usually only a feature of Catholic and Orthodox Churches – in favour of images of Blessed President Xi Jinping.
There are fears in Hong Kong, once the Chinese Communist Party is fully at the helm, that Roman Catholic confessionals where penitents speak in absolute confidence to a priest will be bugged. Roman Catholic Priests take a vow “even on pain of death” not to divulge the contents of confessions. After all, if the FBI in the USA can bug confessionals – and it has – then nobody is safe.
Which brings us to “Maomas“, which is not something I made up. This is what the Chinese Government is encouraging Chinese citizens to celebrate at the end of the year. After all, they say, Saint Chairman Mao was the real saviour of China, not Jesus Christ.
The prospects for the Catholic Church in our former colony cannot be good. There are nearly 400,000 baptised Catholics of many nationalities over 51 parishes in Hong Kong, most of whom seem to go to mass. Currently, they are not under the control of the Chinese Communist Party. That situation will be intolerable once China assumes full control. There has never been a time when ‘watch (this space) and pray’ can have been more apposite.
Whether you worship Mao, mammon or our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, a Happy Christmas from the MacNab household.
John MacNab teaches at a university in Hong Kong.
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
Atheism and its demons. Prayed in a Catholic Cathedral in Hong Kong some years back. It was full. The Church as an orthodox, rational, confident organisation (which does not describe it under the Free Mason Pope Frank), is an obvious counterpoise to governmental-atheistic power.
Remember that during the Rona Plandemic the Churches were forced into compliance, many closed and worship drastically curtailed. But the massage parlours, brothels, liquor stores, and big-chain grocery stores were fully operational. All hail that ‘science’.
Closing the churches is never by accident.
Indeed.
When I was baptized, I had to be surreptitiously “smuggled” into the church through a back door, with the church closed, because having your child baptized was considered a dangerous act of political defiance that carried serious punishments. (This was back in communist Eastern Europe.)
I wouldn’t be surprised if, at some point in the not too distant future, the situation will be similar in the UK.
Of course not. If there is one thing that defines totalitarianism, it is the refusal of freedom of thought and expression.
It can be done more gently like in modern day Britain. Or more forcefully like in China.
That said, China hasn’t got to the levels of Henry VIII England. At least not yet. But it isn’t that far off.
Close the churches, the pubs, curtail free speech on teh webz – they’re trying to shut us down as a nation.
Across the western world.
To quote president Trump – “fight fight”.
That’s what it’s coming to.
Softlee softlee catchee monkee but the monkey is waking up.
When I worked in HK in the 80’s I went to Midnight Mass in the Catholic Cathedral straight from a boozy party. The Chinese celebrant made a good fist of the mass but the sermon was a killer. First delivered in Cantonese then Mandarin and finally in English. The old lady next to me told me what was going on. It wasn’t a short sermon and my legs were crossed by the end and I was desperate for a pee. Happy days.
Clearly, there is something about Christianity that makes totalitarian powers worried. (And it’s not because Christians are going to put on suicide vests…)
Godless Commie heathen.
An atheistic state is an interesting concept. To proclaim atheism is a bold thing do because it isn’t a position that can be garnered from rationalism or empiricism. The state is unabashedly declaring its own divinity but doing so in such a way that it ultimately undermines itself and thus should see itself as living on borrowed time.
Hmmm… all sounds a bit like the Church of England. (Shortlist for bishops drawn up by the Church, selection made by the Prime Minister on behalf of the King.)
Yes, Hong Kong (Catholic) churches are always packed. Many of the congregants are Philippine nationals working in domestic service in Hong Kong.
I do think we get a somewhat biased view of the situation in Hong Kong from our media. Let’s note first of all that Hong Kong was never democratic under British rule. It was run by a Governor appointed by the British government. Also, the pro-democracy protestors were indeed in effect calling for independence for Hong Kong, because they wanted Hong Kong not to ever be assimilated into China.
As far as I can see, the Chinese government has broadly adhered to the “one country two systems” agreement made with the UK. It is inconceivable and would not be in the interests of Hong Kong for things to stay unchanged there for the 50 years of the agreement, and then the region to suddenly be fully assimilated into the Chinese system. Therefore you would expect gradual change during the 50 years of the agreement, with Hong Kong gradually becoming more like the rest of China. That change process will no doubt continue after the end of the 50 years.
There are many criticisms that can legitimately be made of China. But so far at least, their treatment of Hong Kong has been pretty decent in my opinion.
Completely agree with this. Just like to add that Zen and the HK Free Press are not the most reliable sources.
These photos were taken in Causeway Bay today. Some people obviously didn’t get the memo…
Fascinating and timely article. And a happy Christmas to you and yours, John.