• Login
  • Register
The Daily Sceptic
No Result
View All Result
  • Articles
  • About
  • Archive
    • ARCHIVE
    • NEWS ROUND-UPS
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletter
  • Premium
  • Donate
  • Log In
The Daily Sceptic
No Result
View All Result

No, Keir Starmer, There is No ‘Black Hole’ in Society. The Black Hole is the State

by Dr David McGrogan
21 September 2024 11:00 AM

It is both pompous and trite for a man of middling years, and who has achieved a degree of comfort, to sit around complaining about national decline. But local readers will back me up: national decline is ‘a thing’ here in Britain. It is palpable.

The new(ish) Labour Government has, as I have previously demonstrated, sought to make hay from the ‘lived experience’ of the population in this regard by doubling down on declinism, describing the country as having well and truly gone to the dogs – and itself as the only plausible solution. It has gone about this in a characteristically inept way; rather than providing a message of hope, it seems to be trying to position itself as the political equivalent of a dose of castor oil – foul-tasting but necessary. That might have washed if the voters had a clear idea that there was a credible plan for national renewal in the offing, but this is now true surely of only the most die-hard Labour members. The rest of the population are essentially now just walking around with their fingers collectively crossed behind their backs, clinging to hope but expecting disaster.

Keir Starmer himself seems to be aware of this – he appeared in the news today to display his spectacularly bad political communication skills, declaring that he did not want to rule out certain tax rises in the forthcoming Budget in case it “put the fear of God into people“. Let me tell you – that statement well and truly put the fear of God into me. But it does indicate that the PM has a sense that he may have made a misjudgment in cranking the pessimism to ‘11’ since taking office.

The image which the Government has conjured up to drive this basic point home is that of a “societal black hole“, as distinct from a mere economic one. The idea here would seem to be that the previous Government was so bad that it even managed to damage the very fabric of society, let alone the economy. But it is also what, I believe, poker players would call a ‘tell’. Yes, the Government appears to be saying, the economy has gone off the rails, and yes, the evil Tories played their part, but the real problem is you, the people, for being so foolish as to vote for the Conservatives in the first place (not to mention Brexit), and probably making foolish financial decisions to boot. The underlying message that is transmitted is: “Society, which is to say, the stupid and hateful proles, are the ones who’ve got us into this mess, and now we, the grown-ups, the sensibles, the experts, have to come along and fix it.”

This, let’s call it the ‘technocrat’s lament’, is entirely to be expected. The discourse that lies at the heart of technocracy is that the population are corrupt and that expert rule is necessary to save them from that inherent corruption; it would be naive to expect anything else from what is, in the end, a basically technocratic Government, which makes absolutely no claim whatsoever to be governing in such a way as to represent what voters actually want.

My own feelings, though, are complicated. It seems to me that, undoubtedly, things are deteriorating, and I have written a lot in this Substack about the roots of that deterioration and its trajectory. The country is in a bad way, and we can concede that to Starmer. But on the other hand, to describe society as being mired in a ‘black hole’ as such is to mischaracterise the matter rather. Society, by which we mean the people of a country in their collective interactions and relationships, is not really the problem; it is everything else – economics, politics, education, technology – that is really going wrong. ‘Society’ does not print money or set interest rates; society does not enforce (or fail to enforce) the criminal law; society does not run schools and hospitals; society does not police (or fail to police) the border or make decisions about immigration or asylum; society does not embark on exorbitantly expensive and corrupt megaprojects; society does not set climate change policy. It is the state that does those things. Society merely deals with the consequences and responds to the incentives. Yes, society may go wrong, but typically this will be as a result of government policy more than bad decision-making on the part of ordinary men and women guarding their own interests. For the most part, ‘society’ represents a bastion of sanity and reserve.

And it is also true, of course, that when the crash does happen – which I am certain it will – it is society that is going to have to pick up the pieces – and society, rather than the state, in which we will have to deposit our trust and faith in the aftermath as we rebuild.

I was struck by this on a recent visit to my hometown, where I took the photograph that heads this post. The scene depicted in it is the bandstand at the local park near where I grew up, where every day during the school summer holidays an afternoon of entertainment is provided to the local kids for £1 a head – and has been since 1953 (I used to go when I was knee-high-to-a-grasshopper myself). It is exceptionally good value, and genuinely enjoyable – and all basically run at the initiative of local volunteers (the founders having been a married couple who started it for fun). Watching my own children capering about with the others pretending to be one-eyed, one-horned, flying purple people-eaters, while the adults sat about on deckchairs having a moment’s respite, I was reminded that, when left alone, British people are generally pretty good at getting on with things. Problems only tend to arise when their incentives become misaligned due to over-reliance on the state – a sadly very common phenomenon – or, let’s face it, when the state interferes directly.

This is not true in all cases, and we can all think of collective action problems which genuinely need national coordination (such as the policing of the border, or, as is perhaps becoming increasingly apparent, the regulation of smartphone use for children). But by-and-large society as such is the reliable partner in the state-society relationship, and it is society which always has to provide a safety net where state interference messes everything up. Society, in other words, does not tend to fall into black holes. It gets pushed into them – by overzealous regulation – or slips into them as a result of neglect.

It is important, then, that in opposition the Conservative Party – and it is still, rightly or wrongly, the Conservative Party which has to do the work of official opposition – develops this understanding and forges a narrative to counteract Labour’s combination of low expectations and contempt when it comes to what society is capable of. What is needed is really a rhetoric not so much of societal black holes, but societal strength – and therefore of hope. Those two matters – strength and hope – are connected. And at the heart of the relationship between those two things lies the possibility not just of electoral victory for somebody but, vastly more importantly, genuine national renewal. Whether that synergy can be harnessed is another matter. But the fate of the country rests on it – and not what (as Labour believes) the state can do.

Dr. David McGrogan is an Associate Professor of Law at Northumbria Law School. You can subscribe to his Substack – News From Uncibal – here.

Tags: Black holeDeclineKeir StarmerLabourSocietyTechnocracy

Donate

We depend on your donations to keep this site going. Please give what you can.

Donate Today

Comment on this Article

You’ll need to set up an account to comment if you don’t already have one. We ask for a minimum donation of £5 if you'd like to make a comment or post in our Forums.

Sign Up
Previous Post

Training the Next Generation of Thought Police

Next Post

Emma Thompson and Gary Lineker Front Eco-Campaign Despite Hypocritical Jet-Set Lifestyles

Subscribe
Login
Notify of
Please log in to comment

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

19 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
GLT
GLT
4 years ago

What a fantastic essay. Many thanks.

20
0
ANDY MANSELL
ANDY MANSELL
4 years ago
Reply to  GLT

Absolutely. Sums up modern life in general for me.

3
0
Barney McGrew
Barney McGrew
4 years ago

A brilliant article. Many thanks.

11
0
Anton
Anton
4 years ago

Superb. And timely.

12
0
Mike May
Mike May
4 years ago

The latter part of that final paragraph – poetry!

As for the Thursday evening clap-for-key-workers ceremony I doubt I’m the only one eerily minded of Orwell’s two-minutes’ hate from 1984.

25
0
ANDY MANSELL
ANDY MANSELL
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike May

I’ll be honest- I take part. Originally, I thought it a nice idea, but as it dragged on and it became apparent that there were some people clearly watching to see who was and was not complying it started to feel a little creepy and not a little like an episode from ‘The Prisoner’- especially in a small village. I now take part to save my family from being declared ‘unmutual’…

3
0
Bertie Fox
Bertie Fox
4 years ago

Wonderful article! Thank you!!

8
0
rodmclaughlin
rodmclaughlin
4 years ago

Brilliant. Far-ranging analysis of modern society which goes way beyond just a critique of the lockdown.

10
0
Tom
Tom
4 years ago

The emphasis that the government – or, perhaps better, the state – places on citizens’ emotions and perceptions is a hallmark of dystopian societies: in “1984” Winston must not merely say that 2 + 2 = 5, but actually believe it; in Zamyatin’s “We” the state surgically removes the imagination from the population to reduce them to mere functionaries; and in “Brave New World” people are relentlessly conditioned to identify with the state: “everyone’s happy now”. This of course goes hand-in-hand with our new-found love of censorship – “dangerous” is the new “degenerate” – and the constant appeal to security. The principle of individual autonomy – probably the defining idea of the West – is apparently now the greatest threat. Thanks for the article.

14
0
Hieronimusb
Hieronimusb
4 years ago

A good essay which eloquently deconstructs the message but fails to name the ‘science’ behind it: Applied Behavioural Psychology (see Edward Bernays et al). Call it spin, call it what you like, governments have been ramping up their use of it for decades and it is now an insidious virus with far more potential for harm than SARS-COV-2.

15
0
Jacqueline Johnstone
Jacqueline Johnstone
4 years ago
Reply to  Hieronimusb

Susan Michie of Sage, Boris Johnson’s new BF advisor, is one of those (Applied Behavioural Psychologist). An avowed communist to boot. Lordy, Lordy.

1
0
Dene Bebbington
Dene Bebbington
4 years ago

Emotion and fear (whether because of a supposed internal or external threat) have always been two of the many tools of government.

4
0
Dene Bebbington
Dene Bebbington
4 years ago

This quote from Fahrenheit 451 is pretty apt:

“But you can’t make people listen. They have to come round in their own time, wondering what happened and why the world blew up around them.” 

I think a lot of the lockdown supporters have yet to really understand the extent to which the world blew up around them: the avoidable non-Covid deaths and the massive economic damage which means we’re probably in for another 10 years of so-called “austerity”.

10
0
djc
djc
4 years ago
Reply to  Dene Bebbington

“Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.”
Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, Charles Mackay, 1852

8
0
Rachel
Rachel
4 years ago
Reply to  Dene Bebbington

Been speculating they’ll start waking up when they visit Walmart and can’t find their favorite coffee brand on the shelves. “Oh no! Who ever thought economic devastation could disrupt my creaturely comforts while staying home forever.” Or the coffee will be there and suddenly cost $30 a canister instead of $2.50.

1
0
Julian
Julian
4 years ago

Spot on. The PM is at it again in the Mail on Sunday today, saying he understands our “frustration”. In other news, Spain has said it is planning “one last extension” of the emergency decree imposing restrictions, before “most of the country” returns to normality in June. Note how they need to explicitly extend it, in contrast to ours that is more or less open ended (ministers I believe can extend the Coronavirus Act) and how there is no mention of “new normal” (though I have to admit I don’t follow Spanish news closely so I may simply be ignorant of this). Who would have thought a country that has seen a long running fascist dictatorship in living memory would make our government look like sinister despots. I am placing my hope in two things: The strong drive of the British people to go to the pub and to want to make babies, and the strong drive of the government to look like it knows what it is doing when we are the only country in Europe living a “new normal” and the sky has not fallen in for them.

7
0
Rachel
Rachel
4 years ago

The Nanny State has Munchausen’s by Proxy.
Almost as bad across the pond.
Things will change (probably not for the better) come November.

0
0
Melanie Oxbrow
Melanie Oxbrow
4 years ago

Great! Thanks so much for this. If only it could be headline news instead of the lies and scaremongering that has become ‘normal’! Everyone needs to know this.

1
0

NEWSLETTER

View today’s newsletter

To receive our latest news in the form of a daily email, enter your details here:

DONATE

PODCAST

In Episode 35 of the Sceptic: Andrew Doyle on Labour’s Grooming Gang Shame, Andrew Orlowski on the India-UK Trade Deal and Canada’s Ignored Covid Vaccine Injuries

by Richard Eldred
9 May 2025
1

LISTED ARTICLES

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

News Round-Up

9 May 2025

Sun-Dimming Quango has £800 Million of Taxpayer Money to Blow – and a CEO on £450k

8 May 2025

BBC Quietly Edits Question Time After Wrongly ‘Correcting’ Richard Tice on Key Net Zero Claim

9 May 2025

The Sugar Tax Sums Up Our Descent into Technocratic Dystopia

8 May 2025

What Does David Lammy Mean by a State?

9 May 2025

News Round-Up

26

The Sugar Tax Sums Up Our Descent into Technocratic Dystopia

26

Electric Car Bursts into Flames on Driveway and Engulfs £550,000 Family Home

15

“I Was a Super Fit Cyclist Until I Had the Moderna Covid Vaccine. What Happened Next Left Me Wishing I Was Dead”

11

What Does David Lammy Mean by a State?

11

BBC Quietly Edits Question Time After Wrongly ‘Correcting’ Richard Tice on Key Net Zero Claim

9 May 2025

Electric Car Bursts into Flames on Driveway and Engulfs £550,000 Family Home

9 May 2025

“I Was a Super Fit Cyclist Until I Had the Moderna Covid Vaccine. What Happened Next Left Me Wishing I Was Dead”

9 May 2025

Nature Paper Claims to Pin Liability for ‘Climate Damages’ on Oil Companies

9 May 2025

What Does David Lammy Mean by a State?

9 May 2025

POSTS BY DATE

September 2024
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Aug   Oct »

SOCIAL LINKS

Free Speech Union
  • Home
  • About us
  • Donate
  • Privacy Policy

Facebook

  • X

Instagram

RSS

Subscribe to our newsletter

© Skeptics Ltd.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz
No Result
View All Result
  • Articles
  • About
  • Archive
    • ARCHIVE
    • NEWS ROUND-UPS
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletter
  • Premium
  • Donate
  • Log In

© Skeptics Ltd.

You are going to send email to

Move Comment
Perfecty
Do you wish to receive notifications of new articles?
Notifications preferences