122200
  • Log in
The Daily Sceptic
No Result
View All Result
  • Articles
  • About
  • Archive
    • ARCHIVE
    • NEWS ROUND-UPS
  • Forum
  • Donate
  • Newsletter
The Daily Sceptic
No Result
View All Result

Why Do Liberal Left Commentators Pretend it’s Only the Right Who are Fighting a Culture War?

by Toby Young
25 June 2022 5:00 PM
Why Do Liberal Left Commentators Pretend it’s Only the Right Who are Fighting a Culture War?

The journalist and author Ian Leslie has written an excellent Substack post to coincide with the paperback publication of his book Conflicted, now renamed How to Disagree. (You can preorder it on Amazon here.) In the post, he writes about a curious phenomenon whereby commentators on the liberal left tend to brand anyone who challenges the leftward creep of our public institutions as a ‘culture warrior’ and cast them as beyond the pale rather than honestly arguing for the changes that have taken place and which they approve of. This rhetorical move struck me as very similar to the attempt by defenders of scientific orthodoxy when it comes to the pandemic and climate change to sidestep debate by branding any facts that challenge their worldview as ‘misinformation’ and the people who use these facts to question the prevailing orthodoxy as ‘conspiracy theorists’.

On one level, this is perfectly rational behaviour. After all, trying to present your point of view as just a statement of incontrovertible fact – or the logical conclusion that anyone with a functioning moral compass would come to once they’re acquainted with those facts – may be a more effective way of defending that viewpoint than making a more conventional argument. But on the other hand, the attempt to conceal the normative values underpinning that opinion, or denying that it is informed by those values, or acknowledging that it is but pretending there’s nothing remotely contestable about those values, is so fundamentally dishonest it may not be a very effective way of promoting those views in the long run. Indeed, that may be one reason why woke positions seem to be unravelling in some areas – the participation of transwomen in women’s sports, for instance.

Anyway, here’s Ian Leslie on the use of this rhetorical move in the cultural arena.

For me, this tweet encapsulates the way in which the term ‘culture war’ gets used by commentators on the liberal left:

When in doubt, embark on a culture war. These ghouls. https://t.co/9Moi9JrOOP

— Sathnam Sanghera (@Sathnam) June 23, 2022

Background: the OCR, one of Britain’s main exam boards, is reorganising the GCSE poetry syllabus to introduce more ‘accessible’ and ‘diverse’ voices (I put those words in quotation marks because they involve some rather tenuous assumptions), at the expense of poems by Philip Larkin (An Arundel Tomb) and Wilfred Owen (Anthem For Doomed Youth). That, to me, is cultural activism, even if you agree with it.

The OCR is effectively lowering the status of poetic tradition and raising the status of contemporary poetry, in order to meet certain social goals. Just because the decision-makers sit in an office in Cambridge instead of waving placards in the street, and just because they deploy bland language, that doesn’t mean they’re not engaged in politics.

Now, I’m sceptical of the whole exercise – I broadly agree with David James – but even if I thought the OCR was doing something smart and necessary here, I hope I’d be honest enough to admit that this is a politically assertive move, and be willing to defend it as such.

Instead, what happens is that policies like this are presented by left-liberals as apolitical, common sense, quasi-scientific decisions, taken by experts. They’re just the way things are, or have to be. So if anyone voices criticism, as the education secretary does in this case, that can only be because they are unreasonably belligerent.

We’re just taking sensible decisions on your behalf; if you object, you are engaging in a culture war. I’m a moderate, pacific commentator; you are a ghoul.

I have long thought it’s a bit odd quite how much people on the left love to bemoan culture war discourse. They talk about it all the time, despite or perhaps because of the fact the left has made a lot of progress on the cultural battles of recent years and met surprisingly little resistance. But it’s always the other side which makes war, never ‘us’. Meanwhile, to most voters, it’s probably the other way around. The left comes across as more culturally aggressive than the right, the more likely to ‘call out’ incorrect language or behaviour. I don’t think trying to make or police cultural change is necessarily a bad thing, by the way – the left has changed society for the better that way in the past. I just think it’s a bad thing not to be honest about it.

It’s true that the current government pro-actively engages in petty, and frankly futile, provocations, but such tactics are very small fry compared to the way that political, civil, academic and corporate elites have engaged in a stealthy redefinition of what it means to be, say, racist, or a woman. In some ways the discourse around these issues has been changed for the better as a result, in other ways not. But however you look at it, significant changes in cultural norms have been introduced from above, sometimes under the guise of a false consensus.

I think we should stop using culture war as an insult. After all, culture is very important to society and worth arguing over. I’ve written a whole book about how conflict can be productive. But for conflict to be healthy it has to happen out in the open rather than under the table or behind closed doors. It shouldn’t disguise itself as something else. If you think ‘decolonisation’, for example, is a meaningful and necessary activity, then recognise it as a contentious political goal, argue for it on that basis, and welcome counter-arguments. Instead, it gets presented as a neutral, merely bureaucratic term, and the pearl-clutching epithet of ‘culture war’ is wheeled out when anyone questions it. All of the actual arguments are thereby avoided.

Have it out, people! Let’s fight our culture wars honestly.

If you enjoyed that, it’s worth subscribing to The Ruffian, Ian Leslie’s Substack newsletter.

Tags: Culture WarGCSE CurriculumIan LeslieSathnam Sanghera

Donate

We depend on your donations to keep this site going. Please give what you can.

Donate Today

Comment on this Article

You’ll need to set up an account to comment if you don’t already have one. We ask for a minimum donation of £5 if you'd like to make a comment or post in our Forums.

Sign Up
Previous Post

Landmark Study Reveals Devastating Toll of Lockdowns on Children

Next Post

News Round-Up

Subscribe
Login
Notify of
Please log in to comment

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

NEWSLETTER

To view today's newsletter click here

To receive our latest news in the form of a daily email, enter your details here:

DONATE

LISTED ARTICLES

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Editors Picks
1,200 Scientists and Professionals Declare: “There is No Climate Emergency”

1,200 Scientists and Professionals Declare: “There is No Climate Emergency”

18 August 2022
by Chris Morrison
News Round-Up

News Round-Up

17 August 2022
by Jonathan Barr
Most People Infected With Omicron Weren’t Even Aware They Had It

Most People Infected With Omicron Weren’t Even Aware They Had It

18 August 2022
by Toby Young
The Government, the Healthcare Profession and the BBC Have Made Muppets of Us All Over Covid

‘Net Zero’ Groupthink Got Us Into This Mess

18 August 2022
by Jonathan Barr
White House Climate Change Official Sanctioned by National Academy of Sciences for Scientific Misconduct

White House Climate Change Official Sanctioned by National Academy of Sciences for Scientific Misconduct

17 August 2022
by Toby Young
News Round-Up

News Round-Up

59
Most People Infected With Omicron Weren’t Even Aware They Had It

Most People Infected With Omicron Weren’t Even Aware They Had It

25
1,200 Scientists and Professionals Declare: “There is No Climate Emergency”

1,200 Scientists and Professionals Declare: “There is No Climate Emergency”

17
The Government, the Healthcare Profession and the BBC Have Made Muppets of Us All Over Covid

‘Net Zero’ Groupthink Got Us Into This Mess

10
Can Nuclear Energy Save Europe?

Can Nuclear Energy Save Europe?

8
Can Nuclear Energy Save Europe?

Can Nuclear Energy Save Europe?

18 August 2022
by Noah Carl
The U.S. Are Not the Good Guys

The U.S. Are Not the Good Guys

17 August 2022
by Noah Carl
Woke Medicine Abandons Meritocracy and Sense

Woke Medicine Abandons Meritocracy and Sense

15 August 2022
by Noah Carl
No, the Arctic isn’t Warming Four Times Faster Than the Planet

No, the Arctic isn’t Warming Four Times Faster Than the Planet

14 August 2022
by Chris Morrison
The Argumentum Hystericum

The Argumentum Hystericum

14 August 2022
by Dr James Alexander

POSTS BY DATE

June 2022
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  
« May   Jul »

SOCIAL LINKS

Free Speech Union
  • Home
  • About us
  • Donate
  • Privacy Policy

Facebook

Twitter

Instagram

RSS

Subscribe to our newsletter

© 2022 Skeptics Ltd.

No Result
View All Result
  • Articles
  • About
  • Archive
    • ARCHIVE
    • NEWS ROUND-UPS
  • Forum
  • Donate
  • Newsletter

© 2022 Daily Sceptic.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Please note: To be able to comment on our articles you'll need to be a registered donor

Already have an account?
Please click here to login Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz
You are going to send email to

Move Comment