Electric cars kill pedestrians at double the rate of petrol or diesel vehicles, a study in a BMJ journal has found. The Telegraph has more.
Experts said that electric or hybrid cars were twice as likely to be involved in a road accident with a bystander than a petrol or diesel car over the same distance.
The researchers suggested the vehicles’ quieter engines were a significant factor in higher fatality rates and called on the Government to mitigate the risks as it phases out petrol and diesel cars in pursuit of Net Zero.
The study looked at the number of casualties from road collisions in Britain between 2013 and 2017 using Road Safety Data and calculated the number of pedestrians that had been hit by different types of cars.
Over the period, 96,285 pedestrians were hit by a car or taxi. While three-quarters of these people had been hit by a car with a combustion engine, this was because they covered significantly more miles.
To overcome this, the researchers calculated the rate of casualties per 100 million miles covered by electric and hybrid cars compared with petrol and diesel cars.
They found that 5.16 people on average were hit by an electric or hybrid car for every 100 million miles that type of vehicle had driven, compared with 2.4 people for petrol and diesel cars.
The road accident data were cross-referenced with annual mileage figures from the National Travel Survey, with 32 billion miles of electric and hybrid vehicle travel and three trillion miles of petrol and diesel vehicle travel included in the analysis.
Two per cent of the pedestrian casualties were caused by an electric vehicle, while 24% of the accidents did not have a record of the engine type.
The researchers said that even in an “extreme case” scenario where all of these were accidents involving traditional combustion engine cars, the casualty rate would have been 3.16 per 100 million miles, still 63% lower than seen with electric cars.
Worth reading in full.
One potential confounder is that electric cars are more likely to be used on shorter hops in urban areas (due to range constraints) while petrol cars are more likely to be used for long journeys where miles can be racked up with no pedestrians around. It’s not clear how well this issue has been dealt with by the researchers. But still, it makes sense that quieter vehicles will be involved in more incidents with pedestrians – and that heavier vehicles will cause more harm.
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
No no. You’re looking at all those chronic old diseases and problems. Never mind those. Look over here at the new shiny thing. This is the future. This is what matters now.
Sturgeon wants to be a bigger DICKtator than Macron
Refuse to comply and our freedoms won’t die
FRANCE Business’s REFUSE To Enforce PASSPORTS / Hugo Talks Some More
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwNnhrahyW8
Stand in South Hill Park Bracknell every Sunday from 10am meet fellow anti lockdown freedom lovers, keep yourself sane, make new friends and have a laugh.
Join our Stand in the Park – Bracknell – Telegram Group
http://t.me/astandintheparkbracknell
This needs to end now. Don’t comply. Ditch the masks. Protect the children. Updated website with useful information, resources and links: https://www.LCAHub.org/
Both this and the following item (re. education) tell us what we know already.
The problem is that the vast majority just don’t see these local and global imbalances, inequalities and other damage created by lockdowns – they just assume it’s all ‘necessary’ in fighting a terrible plague.
That’s what has to be cut through.
https://medicalxpress.com/news/2021-08-viral-true-indicator-sars-cov-transmission.html
Asymptomatic with COVID transmit it as much as Symptomatic…. Therefore the jab is even more dangerous
Short version: Proponents of current Corona policies convinced that lockdowns work and must be intensified because COVID hasn’t been eradicated yet. We already knew that one since last year.
The remainder of this useless collection of “anecdotes with numbers” can go directly to the bin: If I test positive for Sars-CoV2 and happen to have met someone who also tested positive, that’s not a proof that I got it from him or he from me.
UK approves Moderna’s Covid vaccine for 12 to 17-year-olds after medical watchdog rules jab is safe in children
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9901121/UK-approves-Modernas-Covid-jab-12-17-year-olds.html
Not overly surprised, but still disappointing news.
This will at least be approved as safe and effective way to protect older adults for children aged 3 months and over (or whatever the earliest age for dropping them into a nursery happens to be).
Some positive news – Dandelion Root extract can block Spike Protein. Invitro studies found Taraxacum Officinale has positive benefits for SP exposure arising from SARS-CoV-2. Root decoction found to be anticoagulant, anti-adhesive, anti-aggregation, anti-oxidative.
https://twitter.com/ukmfa1/status/1427601233083240454?s=20
Careful now, the French call dandelion piss-en-lit for a reason, it is highyl diuretic. A friend used to make dandelion coffee which was delicious but best drunk close to a toilet.
I will drink to that.
The bit I was expecting:
we need to redouble our efforts by reducing the availability of alcohol, restricting its marketing and by uprating minimum unit price.
Obviously the only thing one can possibly do when policies said to improve so-called public health end up pushing people into so-called problem drinking: We are never wrong, the other’s are just inherently wicked!
What the Grauniad doesn’t mention, but to be fair, Al Beeb does, is that the Scotch actually drank less last year, so the minimum pricing is “working”.
However, what it’s doing is reducing the moderate drinking that wasn’t a problem, not the addiction drinking that is.
This happens to be one area where the Americans are actually ahead of us (and significantly so): They consider substance abuse a mental disorder which might require treatment and not an excuse to punish the people affected by it.
Like high tax Skandiland, the minimum pricing nonsense boosts alternative alcohol sources.
Day 1 of Nicola Stalins min pricing & majestic wines open a new warehouse in Berwick on Tweed – funny that.
Amazon & all the online wine beer websites were sold out of many of their product lines last year.
(Just for info Norway has super high tax on alcohol & is one of the worlds biggest consumers of sugar – who thinks they are putting it on cornflakes and not stills)
This is a fact comiong from one who lives in Norway. The Norwegians go to Sweden, the Swedes go to Denmark, the Danes go to Germany, the Germans go to Poland and the Czech Republic etc etc…… And yes, home distilling is a big thing in Norway, I don’t know many people who either don’t have a still or don’t know someone that has…
Correct. And entirely foreseeable.
Read what I said above. Addicts will make their own booze, whether it be beer wine or spirits. And these drinks will not be reflected in any statistics.
Yes but the nasty nats need to make life worth living as well.
Such stupid policies only lead to people making their own spirits.This happened in Sweden until they joined the EU and the prices of alcohol became lower. My ex had his own still and regularly made his own pure alcohol on top of the cooker. The result was disgusting, even orange juice could not disguise the awful taste. And people get ill drinking it.
Now, come on, be fair, this isn’t the whole story.
We also had record drug deaths last year as well.
How’s that minimum alcohol pricing working out?
What!?! You’re saying mind altering chemical use has a high degree of fungibility and pushing one away from legal use drives one into less pure illegal drugs?
Sturgeon want to be a bigger DICKtator than Macron
Refuse to comply and our freedoms won’t die
FRANCE Business’s REFUSE To Enforce PASSPORTS / Hugo Talks Some More
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwNnhrahyW8
Stand in South Hill Park Bracknell every Sunday from 10am meet fellow anti lockdown freedom lovers, keep yourself sane, make new friends and have a laugh.
Join our Stand in the Park – Bracknell – Telegram Group
http://t.me/astandintheparkbracknell
That headline is illiterate.
Probably an in-joke against the Scots (whose education system pre-SNP was pretty good)!
Since the Natzis started interfering Scots education has tumbled down the PISA scorecard.
A 3% decrease in suicides in Scotland in 2020? Sorry, but that simply cannot be true. That would be like claiming there was also a decrease in domestic violence.
Yes – how many got re-classified as covid to protect the witch of the north from accusations that she has mis-managed mental health (as well as essentially everything else)?
Well, well, what a surprise – whoever would have guessed that might happen?
Every which way they win don’t they. Suicides, alcohol deaths and drugs, heart attacks and strokes caused by the extreme stress they have caused. Lives cut short because of all the harms caused by fear, lockdowns and isolation. The list of ways they have killed people just goes on and on. And they stand by and rub their hands with glee.
Wot, put people under virtual house arrest for months, shut down most sport and outdoor activities, close all supervised drinking establishments, wreck education, expect people to sit indoors through a Northern winter with up to 7 hours of daylight a day, then look surprised when people drink for something to do.
What have the nasty nats done about the Buckfast triangle anyway? Has minimum pricing actually helped?
As with everything, they cannot contemplate that their own authoritarian policies but be problematic. They will not accept that lockdown, mask wearing and so on are destroying mental health. Neither can they accept that minimum pricing is a failure: their response will be to raise the price further.
Anxiety and depression increase. Illegal drugs, and black market booze, cheaper than legal alcohol. Criminals prosper. Violent crime goes up. A total disaster, which the wonderful, caring govern will fix – by using the same failed policies.
Some years ago I worked in a liaison role between industry and the government and used to get a lot of information from the Welsh and Scottish ‘governments’. Most of it consisted of them crowing about some new type of petty state interference in the private lives of citizens.
It’s notable from the article that when listing actions which must be taken to address the problem, Alison Douglas, the chief executive of Alcohol Focus Scotland, made a number of recommendations which all involve Governmental/Quangocracy expanding their powers …… but failed to identify the cause of increased drinking and the remedy:
STOP LOCKING DOWN.
Won’t matter when Stasi Sturgeon brings about prohibition. She already does very little to protect our Whisky on the world stage.
Highest drug related deaths
Highest alcohol related deaths
Highest suicide deaths
The average life expectancy of a man in areas of Glasgow the same as a man in sub-Saharan Africa.
Education attainment gap off the scale.
But it’s OK. Everyone should keep wearing a mask – forever. That’ll sort it.