A strange intervention has given another twist to the farce of the Benin bronzes. Nigerian Prince Nosuyi Ovonramwen has suggested in a blog post that “descendants of the slaves” (referring to the ones Benin sold) should be allowed to “share in the value of the bronzes”. Surely, a call to sell up and distribute the proceeds?
A British expedition of 1897 overthrew Oba (King) Ovonramwen and his regime in Benin, which still gloried in mass human sacrifice of slaves and war captives. Slaves were freed, the mass murders stopped, and Ovonramwen’s son was reinstated in 1914, with his line continuing to today’s essentially ceremonial Oba Ewuare II. Prince Ovonramwen, who lives in Nigeria, is the overthrown Oba’s great-great-grandson, which is why his opinion carries weight.
Thousands of bronze, ivory and wooden artefacts were removed from Benin in 1897 and ended up in the world’s museums, the bronzes widely admired for their sophisticated casting, evidence of unsuspected artistic skills in Africa in the Middle Ages. Until March this year, Nigeria’s campaign to get the artworks restituted was going nicely, with well-intentioned (or colonial-guilt-obsessed) curators and trustees handing collections to Nigeria’s Museums Commission (NCMM, that is, the Nigerian people): Jesus College, the Smithsonian, London’s Horniman Museum, and most spectacularly, 1,130 of pieces in Germany’s state museums – with more in prospect.
As the Daily Sceptic reported on May 15th, Nigeria’s President quietly decreed in March that everything restituted to the NCMM would in fact be handed to Oba Ewuare, as his private property: past auction records show these pieces have huge market value, the record currently standing at £10m for a bronze head. The President’s bombshell brought restitutions to a halt. Cambridge’s Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology had a rethink only days before handing over more than 100 pieces, and German curators and politicians have tried to face down the uproar (only a couple of dozen pieces having left Germany so far).
It remains to be seen what these trustees and curators will make of a Benin Prince’s idea that their museums’ works should now be sold by Nigeria and the money handed out. Nothing of what has already been restituted has been seen by the Nigerian people, and no-one will say where those works are today. Three important ones, stolen from Lagos Museum some years ago, ended up in New York’s Met Museum, but after having been sent back yet again they’ve vanished.
Meantime the Restitution Study Group, speaking for millions of American and Caribbean descendants of the slaves whom Benin and other African kingdoms sold, is gaining support for its claim that the bronzes should stay on display where they are, around the world, as memorials to the sufferings of their ancestors and to shame those who captured and sold them to foreign traders.
Professor Brigitta Hauser-Schäublin wrote in May about the shambles of the restitution process from a German viewpoint and on August 6th she published another trenchant article in Neue Zürcher Zeitung, saying that the post-colonial debate has been missing the point – the ‘victims’ are not the Benin kingdom, but its slaves; and that as slavery was abolished slave owners in British and French colonies were handsomely compensated – she gives surprising figures – but the slaves themselves got nothing.
She ends by arguing:
The recent history of the bronzes has been accompanied by a change in meaning: as the embodiment of ancestors, they were persons, instruments of power and objects of worship. But with the British subjugation of Benin they lost their sacred character; they became spoils of war, commodities to be sold on the art market and private property. A large part ended up in public museums around the world as cultural assets, where they became what they are today: a first-class cultural World Heritage.
All those whose actions and suffering are embodied in the artefacts have rights to them. They and all those connected to them – indeed, all of us – are entitled to co-ownership. It is time to give up the exclusive concept of private property of cultural assets in favour of a communal concept of ownership. ‘Shared heritage’, in other words.
It’s worth reading in full, she demolishes the idea that the Benin works are nothing more than stolen private property.
Hauser-Schäublin’s article is headed by pictures of a carved wooden box from Benin which she noticed in Hamburg’s MARKK Museum. It glorifies human sacrifice. On one end, an executioner brandishes his sword over a headless corpse with bound legs and arms; on the lid an official displays a severed head while drummers celebrate.
But images like this from Benin itself, giving the local view of what went on there, might vanish from the world: the Smithsonian is among museums which have handed to Nigeria image rights in artworks along with the pieces themselves. The Obas have never apologised for their ancestors’ murderous, slave-trading past: why would they want the world to see the evidence?
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
Note to the moderator. My account has been hacked. My posting history has been deleted and when I try to access the “my content and setting” link at the head of the the post I get an insulting response. Please delete this message when you have read it and advise me what action to take other that change my password which I have done.
My posting history is similarly unavailable. When I try to access it I get the message “N0nc€ is invalid. Only it’s spelt correctly. I don’t remember using that word in a comment, perhaps I was infuriated by something someone at the BBC had done, they do seem to glorify pedophiles somewhat…
Try editing your post and see whether you are told that you are posting too quickly when you click Edit
Sorry, when you click Save – I couldn’t edit it to correct it.
That message crops up occasionally and I just log out and log back in.
Nonce is a technical term. Don’t worry, DS is not calling you a nonce. They’ve got their encryption in a mess…
Nonce: random or semi-random number that is generated for a specific use. It is related to cryptographic communication and information technology (IT). The term stands for “number used once” or “number once” and is commonly referred to as a cryptographic nonce.
Thanks for the clarification MAk, as does the “Posting too fast – slow down” message. Clearly abbreviations not intended to be seen by the public.
Okey dokey
Same here, Boomer, I don’t think it’s anything to do with your previous comments. Come on, DS, sort it out! By the way, I’ve never knew you could look at your posting history but mine doesn’t exist either!
I have also set up a completely new account and it is similarly afflicted so it is a site hack, not directed at me personally.
Did you email the DS team yet? Perhaps get back to us with their response, seeing as this is an issue that isn’t affecting you alone. I think this site also suffers from glitches on a regular basis. It’s obviously seen as a threat! lol
Yes. Response from Toby acknowledging that they are trying to sort it.
I’ve had a look, and your past comments are still in the database (2,286 of them), so it’s presumably some kind of UI bug. However, I’m not sure what you’re looking at – are you referring to My Account->Post View Stats, or somewhere else?
As to the comment rate limiting / flood prevention, I’ve turned that off.
Thanks for the response, Ian.
Ah, I see. I get the same error. Looks like a bug introduced in the latest version of the comments software, which was released earlier this week. I’ll file a bug report.
Software bugs have been the bane of my working life and seem to pursuing me into retirement!
I knew it wasn’t a scam. I got an email from a Nigerian Prince 2 weeks ago saying he was selling the bronzes and if I could give him my bank details he would deposit the money there for safe keeping…only happy to help!
Excellent! Never interrupt a fool.
Such nice people.
I think we need Diane Abbot piercing insight in all matters Black, to guide us through this tangled web.