A new school lesson suggesting Joan of Arc was “non-binary” has ignited fierce backlash from academics and women’s rights advocates. The Mailhas the story.
The Who We Are anthology, published by Collins, features a lesson plan which contains a biography of the French heroine which states “Joan of Arc (1412-31) is today considered by some to have been non-binary.”
The wording has caused fury among some in the academic community, with one professor calling it “insulting” and a women’s rights campaigner calling it “another ridiculous example of attempting to rewrite history.”
Born as a peasant girl around 1412, Joan of Arc became a knight and ultimately a patron saint of France after helping to repulse an English attempt to conquer her nation.
Believing she was enacting God’s will, she led the French army to victory at Siege of Orléans in 1429, a tipping point in the Hundred Years’ War between France and England.
Joan famously had short hair and took to wearing male clothing, a key fact against held her during her trial for heresy in 1431, which ultimately led to her being burnt at the stake.
However, she never claimed to be anything other than female and did not use the term ‘non-binary’ which only gained traction in the 1990s.
“Joan of Arc fought as a woman and died as a woman,” Robert Tombs, Professor Emeritus of French History at the University of Cambridge, told the Telegraph.
“To call her something else is insulting to her and indirectly to all women who are brave enough to risk their lives for their beliefs – as if women are incapable of heroism.”
“This is yet another ridiculous example of attempting to rewrite history and erase strong, rebellious female characters from our past,” Carolyn Brown, of the Women’s Rights Network, added. …
In the summer of 2022, the Globe theatre hosted a play called ‘I, Joan’ which prompted controversy after portraying Joan as non-binary.
Pre-publicity used the pronouns ‘they’ and ‘them’ when referring to the French historical figure.
The theatre defended itself and insisted Shakespeare would have approved.
Stop Press: For schools to traduce the memory of a young woman who died for God and for France is to add insult to injury, says the Telegraph in a leading article.
You’ll need to set up an account to comment if you don’t already have one. We ask for a minimum donation of £5 if you'd like to make a comment or post in our Forums.
GB News understands that the remark sparked widespread diplomatic concerns in Yerevan, with Armenian officials engaging with the British Foreign Office for clarification.
Clarification? It seems clear enough to me. The man is an idiot. A further example of him meddling in issues he knows nothing about – though in this case he’s supposed to know something about it as it’s his ministerial responsibility.
War Is Peace. Freedom Is Slavery. Ignorance Is Strength.
Nagorno-Karabakh is liberated.
bertieboy
6 months ago
Seriously, this man should be removed from representing this country. It is now beyond embarrassing and the potential for a serious diplomatic incident cannot be ruled out. One can only hope that his ignorance is now so obvious to all that those affected by his comments will make allowances for his lamentable grasp of geopolitics.
…. or perhaps use the phrase which my long deceased father-in-law used to describe other drivers who annoyed him (in a broad Mancunian accent) – ‘Berking Twithead’!
The ‘cleansing’ of Christians from their enclave in Muslim Azerbaijan was merely a continuation of the ‘cleansing’ of non-muslims, primarily Christians & Jews that has been going on for over a century.
You don’t have to go back very far to find that Christians made up about a 3rd of many middle Eastern countries. Even in countries such as Egypt Christians constituted about 25% of the population.
Population in the region throws up some interesting points. Who would have thought that in Israel & the Palestinian Territories there are about 7.2m Jews & 7.1m Arabs, & a further 0.5m Christians.
A mixing of terms there. I assume you mean that the 7.1m Arabs are all Muslims?
Jews and Christians are members of religious groups and not necessarily of a particular ethnicity. ‘Arab’ is a purely ethnic term – though there are many different ethnic sub-groups.
Jews are a race; there are very few who follow the religion of Judaism who are not also Jews but they are not the same thing. There are plenty of non-religious Jews.
Was 100 percent Christian until Islam came along and forcibly converted or killed the Christians of the middle east. The crusades were a long overdue response to religious invaders.
Richard Austin
6 months ago
Why is the Labour party so chock bang full of Gobs on Legs with no brain cell to share between them?
Lammy is an antisemitic racist. Who is responsible for putting him in arguably the most important position in Government? The man is a walking time bomb.
Rayner is a foul-mouthed thief.
Two-Tier is a money-grubbing disgrace to himself, let alone to the country. What kind of person, let alone a multi-millionaire, whines they wouldn’t be able to watch football without freebies? How come the future King and his son sit in the stands at Villa Park. Bring on the pictures of Arsenal v Villa.
If the world thought Biden embarrassing wait until they pick up on this lot!
I very confidently give Reeves 10 months, Two-Tier 2 Years before his party kick him out. They will have no choice, he is fast heading towards the most unpopular leader ever, even eclipsing a PM who sent British troops to die. It really is that serious.
“Two-Tier is a money-grubbing disgrace to himself, let alone to the country. What kind of person, let alone a multi-millionaire, whines they wouldn’t be able to watch football without freebies?”
Two Tier Starmer is so last week as is “Kier Starmer, Granny Harmer”.
Lammy is just sticking to the woke script: Muslims did this to Christians. Hence, it must have been a good thing. Whatever it was.
Atticus
6 months ago
Two Lammy pieces in fairly close succession is too much to bear. Do you remember the Spitting Image sketch in the 80s about Reagan? The President has lost his brain? Did our For Sec ever have one I wonder?
It is now abundantly clear that Kneel was told who to give which job to whom on the basis that they are wholly unsuited to the roles they have been given.
Lammy – so utterly thick that he doesn’t know which order 7 an 8 belong in, wholly ignorant of British history and with a gob as big as the Mersey Tunnel such that a major diplomatic incident is a case of when not if.
Ranting Rayner – in charge of housing. She who stole off taxpayers via a housing deal. Streetwise but also utterly thick.
Robber Reeves – ex Bank of England (brewer up presumably ) as Treasurer. We couldn’t make this up.
On and on it goes – Miilibrain etc. Most of the current lot could outdo Abbacus Abbott in the absence of grey matter.
EppingBlogger
6 months ago
i think Azerbiyan is one of the places Blair advised on how to get western support.
JXB
6 months ago
Good. We should follow his advice and start with him.
Pete Sutton
6 months ago
Lame-brain Lammy’s future is on the speech making circuit – “how I started WWIII” plus his ever popular party piece, “Kings and Queens of England (in reverse order)”.
Enough. This is the UK foreign secretary you’re talking about. One of the top cabinet positions. How on Earth would he have got the job if he wasn’t amazing at thinking?
Hilarious!
Here’s an idea for the next cabinet reshuffle….
Lammy for education secretary !
Pilla
6 months ago
Is Lammy being unbelievably stupid and ignorant or does he actually think it’s a good thing for Nagorno-Karabakh to be ethnically cleansed (and Armenia also at risk)? Could he really be this ignorant? If so, why on earth is he in the position he is?
RTSC
6 months ago
You’d think the primary quality the Foreign Secretary should demonstrate is diplomacy.
Free Gear Keir has appointed a loudmouth bigot, who’s an embarrassment to the country.
Lammy Didn’t Earn It.
Grim Ace
6 months ago
Lammy is a great example of why immigration is a really bad idea. He is thick as mince. His best role would be as burger flipper in McDonalds.
This government is riven with stupid, ignorant idiot communists. In fact, I reckon most of them are so thick, they don’t even understand communism.
The only useful role Lammy has is to make the rest of his colleagues feel superior!
bertieboy
6 months ago
I’m still struggling to believe this! You’ll know the feeling when your mind takes time to absorb information and you get waves of disbelief.
Before his appointment to this intellectually demanding position it was already known be was an idiot. Only an imbecile would put him into this role.
Last edited 6 months ago by bertieboy
Simon MacPhisto
6 months ago
Lammy’s a national embarrassment on the world stage. Not in my name, doesn’t represent my views, looks like an imposter, an utter shambles of a man in a government of similar talent.
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
Good grief, this idiot is going to end up taking us into a war by his stupidity.
Caution, Brain free zone.
He’s as dangerous and as mad as Bunter and Cameron isn’t he.
A whole lot worse.
Clarification? It seems clear enough to me. The man is an idiot. A further example of him meddling in issues he knows nothing about – though in this case he’s supposed to know something about it as it’s his ministerial responsibility.
War Is Peace. Freedom Is Slavery. Ignorance Is Strength.
Nagorno-Karabakh is liberated.
Seriously, this man should be removed from representing this country. It is now beyond embarrassing and the potential for a serious diplomatic incident cannot be ruled out. One can only hope that his ignorance is now so obvious to all that those affected by his comments will make allowances for his lamentable grasp of geopolitics.
…
will make allowances for his lamentable grasp of geopolitics.“…will make allowances for his lamentable grasp of basic knowledge and common sense.”
With all due respect but we might as well be blunt and say it how it is.
…. or perhaps use the phrase which my long deceased father-in-law used to describe other drivers who annoyed him (in a broad Mancunian accent) – ‘Berking Twithead’!
We know why he was chosen and it certainly wasn’t for his intellect!
The ‘cleansing’ of Christians from their enclave in Muslim Azerbaijan was merely a continuation of the ‘cleansing’ of non-muslims, primarily Christians & Jews that has been going on for over a century.
You don’t have to go back very far to find that Christians made up about a 3rd of many middle Eastern countries. Even in countries such as Egypt Christians constituted about 25% of the population.
Population in the region throws up some interesting points. Who would have thought that in Israel & the Palestinian Territories there are about 7.2m Jews & 7.1m Arabs, & a further 0.5m Christians.
A mixing of terms there. I assume you mean that the 7.1m Arabs are all Muslims?
Jews and Christians are members of religious groups and not necessarily of a particular ethnicity. ‘Arab’ is a purely ethnic term – though there are many different ethnic sub-groups.
Jews are a race; there are very few who follow the religion of Judaism who are not also Jews but they are not the same thing. There are plenty of non-religious Jews.
I’d disagree with you on jews being a race its a religion however as you say not all jews are religious but the same could be said for every religion!
Are Eastern European Khazarians part of the Jewish ‘race’? They don’t look like they are descended from the Levant..
Was 100 percent Christian until Islam came along and forcibly converted or killed the Christians of the middle east. The crusades were a long overdue response to religious invaders.
Why is the Labour party so chock bang full of Gobs on Legs with no brain cell to share between them?
Lammy is an antisemitic racist. Who is responsible for putting him in arguably the most important position in Government? The man is a walking time bomb.
Rayner is a foul-mouthed thief.
Two-Tier is a money-grubbing disgrace to himself, let alone to the country. What kind of person, let alone a multi-millionaire, whines they wouldn’t be able to watch football without freebies? How come the future King and his son sit in the stands at Villa Park. Bring on the pictures of Arsenal v Villa.
If the world thought Biden embarrassing wait until they pick up on this lot!
I very confidently give Reeves 10 months, Two-Tier 2 Years before his party kick him out. They will have no choice, he is fast heading towards the most unpopular leader ever, even eclipsing a PM who sent British troops to die. It really is that serious.
“Two-Tier is a money-grubbing disgrace to himself, let alone to the
country. What kind of person, let alone a multi-millionaire, whines they
wouldn’t be able to watch football without freebies?”
Two Tier Starmer is so last week as is “Kier Starmer, Granny Harmer”.
His new name in the hood is: “Free Gear Starmer”.
Free Gear Two-Tier Kier
I’m also shocked at how completely clueless and dangerous these imbeciles are and the sooner they are removed the better for our country.
At least you know and expect this sort of thing from Labour. It’s those Janus faced, fakeTories that are worse than rats.
Lammy is just sticking to the woke script: Muslims did this to Christians. Hence, it must have been a good thing. Whatever it was.
Two Lammy pieces in fairly close succession is too much to bear. Do you remember the Spitting Image sketch in the 80s about Reagan? The President has lost his brain? Did our For Sec ever have one I wonder?
The man’s an utter cretin and a dangerous liability.
Its simple really, in order to lose something you have to have one to start with!
He doesn’t need to retract his statement or issue a clarification.
He needs to expletive deleted well resign, and pronto.
He is a national and international laughing stock, a man of peerless stupity even in 2tk’s cabinet of imbeciles.
Go for heavens sake GO!
Come on, 2TStarmer should sack him, but he won’t! To do so would be racist!
What this country desperately needs is a “fit for office” test.
Lammy would certainly fail almost any device to measure this.
It is now abundantly clear that Kneel was told who to give which job to whom on the basis that they are wholly unsuited to the roles they have been given.
Lammy – so utterly thick that he doesn’t know which order 7 an 8 belong in, wholly ignorant of British history and with a gob as big as the Mersey Tunnel such that a major diplomatic incident is a case of when not if.
Ranting Rayner – in charge of housing. She who stole off taxpayers via a housing deal. Streetwise but also utterly thick.
Robber Reeves – ex Bank of England (brewer up presumably
) as Treasurer. We couldn’t make this up.
On and on it goes – Miilibrain etc. Most of the current lot could outdo Abbacus Abbott in the absence of grey matter.
i think Azerbiyan is one of the places Blair advised on how to get western support.
Good. We should follow his advice and start with him.
Lame-brain Lammy’s future is on the speech making circuit – “how I started WWIII” plus his ever popular party piece, “Kings and Queens of England (in reverse order)”.
He looks a bit like a Sontaran warrior in this picture but the Sontarans are courageous and honourable so maybe not…
I think he looks more like Jabba the Hutt.
Well spotted
Similar moral sense too
Enough. This is the UK foreign secretary you’re talking about. One of the top cabinet positions. How on Earth would he have got the job if he wasn’t amazing at thinking?
Hilarious!
!
Here’s an idea for the next cabinet reshuffle….
Lammy for education secretary
Is Lammy being unbelievably stupid and ignorant or does he actually think it’s a good thing for Nagorno-Karabakh to be ethnically cleansed (and Armenia also at risk)? Could he really be this ignorant? If so, why on earth is he in the position he is?
You’d think the primary quality the Foreign Secretary should demonstrate is diplomacy.
Free Gear Keir has appointed a loudmouth bigot, who’s an embarrassment to the country.
Lammy Didn’t Earn It.
Lammy is a great example of why immigration is a really bad idea. He is thick as mince. His best role would be as burger flipper in McDonalds.
This government is riven with stupid, ignorant idiot communists. In fact, I reckon most of them are so thick, they don’t even understand communism.
The only useful role Lammy has is to make the rest of his colleagues feel superior!
I’m still struggling to believe this! You’ll know the feeling when your mind takes time to absorb information and you get waves of disbelief.
Before his appointment to this intellectually demanding position it was already known be was an idiot. Only an imbecile would put him into this role.
Lammy’s a national embarrassment on the world stage. Not in my name, doesn’t represent my views, looks like an imposter, an utter shambles of a man in a government of similar talent.
God help us all – what chance do we have with such low quality ‘politicians’ as this current lot! I have never felt so fearful for our future
Sadly our future was just as grim under the Tories
And has Welby come out in defence of Armenian Christians ??