The election is over and we all know Labour has won with a massive majority. New ministers have been appointed to the Department of Energy and Net Zero (DESNZ) and the hard job of Government has begun.
Labour has appointed six ministers to DESNZ. However, analysis of their background and experience (see below) reveals two with PPE degrees, one with a degree in history, another with a degree in political studies and one with a degree in history and politics. There’s also one minister gaining a degree in Russian studies before studying law. Not one of them has a background in science, engineering or maths. Almost all of them have worked in the public sector for their whole lives, so between them, there is precious little experience of the commercial world and no experience of the energy sector. Ed Miliband and Miatta Fahnbulleh have qualifications in economics, but the latter describes herself as a “heterodox economist” and she has advocated “flooding the market with cheaper renewables” and introducing “free basic energy”. It can only be ‘heterodox economists’ who think more expensive, intermittent renewables are cheap and think energy is free.
There are three spads listed for Ed Miliband. Jonty Leibowitz studied history at Cambridge. Tobias Garnett studied law at City and then went to study at the Harvard Kennedy School where his thesis was entitled ‘A Just Transition to a Fairer Economy: Labour’s plan for a Green Industrial Revolution.’ Eleanor Salter is the final spad, shared with DEFRA, and it is unclear what her degree subject was but she writes for the Guardian and apparently she is particularly focused on “integrating nature into the climate offer”. No evidence of STEM backgrounds amongst the spads either.
You might think this does not matter, because ministers simply oversee the department and it is civil servants that really run the show. There are seven senior civil servants listed on the DESNZ website. But when you look at their background a similar picture emerges (see below). There are degrees in modern history, geography and modern languages, but precious little evidence of a STEM background anywhere. Only the Chief Scientific Advisor has any sort of science background and that is in chemistry, with a special focus on astrochemistry. Furthermore, there is no evidence that the senior civil servants have any significant experience outside the public sector. There is no evidence of experience in proper commercial businesses in any sector, let alone energy.
The rot does not stop in DESNZ. The department might turn to advisors like the National Grid Electricity System Operator, who have recently published their future energy pathways. Their Strategy and Policy Director, Claire Dykta, oversaw the work and wrote the foreword to the new document. Claire describes herself as a “leading influencer in the energy industry”, as though she was running a TikTok channel. Claire graduated from Aston with a degree in management, business and law, so no evidence of a STEM background either.
DESNZ ministers might look to the Climate Change Committee for advice or instructions. The CCC is currently without a chairman and CEO, but former chairman Lord Deben has a degree in history and former CEO Chris Stark studied finance and law. Despite never delivering anything more taxing than pizza, Stark has been drafted in to lead mission control to deliver a decarbonised grid by 2030. It is thought that Emma Pinchbeck, CEO of renewables cheerleader Energy U.K., is going to take over as CEO of the CCC. Emma has a classics degree from Oxford and began her career as a climate campaigner for WWF. Again, we find no evidence of any STEM expertise or proper commercial experience. The CCC does have some engineers and scientists on the board, but many of them have drunk the Kool-Aid, have interests in renewable energy or get their funding from billionaire climate activists.
Not only does Mad Emperor Miliband have no clothes, his entire entourage have Net Zero garments. We have the blind leading the blind, advised by clueless cronies who do not have the faintest idea about energy, engineering or the commercial world. They simply don’t know what they don’t know and are totally ill-equipped to challenge the tendentious twaddle put before them. Their idea of delivery is drawing boxes and triangles on PowerPoint presentations. Some of them might even be numerate enough to plug numbers into spreadsheets, but they do not have the faintest idea what their models mean in the real world. This is how we get plans for energy that halve per capita energy use by 2050, and nobody bats an eyelid. The entire energy policy establishment is broken.
The biographies of DESNZ ministers and senior civil servants are reproduced below.
DESNZ Labour Ministers
Labour has appointed six ministers to DESNZ:
- Ed Miliband as Secretary of State
- Sarah Jones as Minister of State
- Lord Hunt of Kings Heath as Minister of State
- Kerry McCarthy as Parliamentary Under-Secretary
- Miatta Fahnbulleh as Parliamentary Under-Secretary
- Michael Shanks as Parliamentary Under-Secretary
Let us look at their background and experience.
Ed Miliband
Ed and his brother David are the sons of Ralph Miliband who has been described as “one of the best-known academic Marxists of his generation”. Ed Miliband studied PPE at Corpus Christi College, Oxford, received a master’s in Economics at LSE and was then briefly a researcher for A Week in Politics before he was recruited to work as a researcher and speech writer for Harriet Harman, later becoming a spad for Gordon Brown in 1997. After a brief sabbatical at Harvard, and more advisory work on the Council of Economic Advisors, he became the MP for Doncaster North in 2005. In 2008, he became the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change and announced that the U.K. would oblige itself to cut emissions by 80% by 2050, instead of the previously announced 60%.
Since then, he has held various positions, including Leader of the Opposition. However, it is noteworthy, that he has held no job outside of politics and media, and certainly has no first-hand knowledge of energy or engineering.
Sarah Jones MP
Sarah Jones read History at Durham and joined the Labour Party in 1992, and worked for Labour MP Mo Mowlam. She has also worked for Shelter and as the Head of Public Affairs for the NHS Confederation. Sarah served as a senior civil servant helping to deliver the 2012 Olympics and held various other roles, including working for Gatwick Airport. She was elected to Parliament in 2017 and, since then, she has chaired an APPG on knife crime and been a Shadow Minister for Housing and, later, Shadow Minister for the Police and Fire Service. Again, it is difficult to find any specific energy or engineering expertise.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath
Lord Hunt graduated in 1970 from the University of Leeds with a degree in political studies. His working career was in the healthcare sector, and since being elevated to the Lords, he has held ministerial positions in Health, Department for Work and Pensions, DEFRA and the Department of Energy and Climate Change. It is difficult to find any evidence of him ever working (other than as a minister) in energy or engineering, or indeed outside the public sector.
Kerry McCarthy MP
Kerry McCarthy read Russian Studies at Liverpool University before studying law at the City of London Polytechnic. She has worked as a lawyer for Abbey National and Merrill Lynch and held senior positions at Britain in Europe and the Waterfront Partnership. She was elected to Parliament in 2005 and has held various shadow ministerial positions, becoming Shadow Minister for Climate Change in 2022. Once again, we find no experience in energy, engineering, or STEM.
Miatta Fahnbulleh MP
Miatta Fahnbulleh studied PPE at Lincoln College, Oxford, and then gained a PhD in Economic Development from the LSE. She has described herself as a heterodox economist and, whilst head of the New Economics Foundation (NEF), certainly advocated some, shall we say, unconventional policies. These include “flooding the energy market with cheap renewables and introducing free basic energy”. Miatta and NEF have also advocated an additional windfall tax on oil and gas companies. Miatta was promoted to a ministerial position just a few days after first being elected to Parliament this year. Perhaps she might find these cheap renewables under a magic money tree. Again, no STEM experience and no experience of the private sector.
Michael Shanks MP
Michael Shanks graduated from the University of Glasgow with a degree in History and Politics. He worked in a charity for a while before becoming a teacher. He taught Modern Studies at a school in Scotland. He was elected to Parliament in a by-election in December 2023. Yet another minister without STEM experience and no experience of the commercial world.
Senior DESNZ Civil Servants
There are six senior civil servants in DESNZ, supported by a chief scientific advisor. These are:
- Jeremy Pocklington – Permanent Secretary
- Clive Maxwell – Second Permanent Secretary
- Jonathan Mills – Director General Energy and Markets Supply
- Ashley Ibbett – Director General of Energy Infrastructure
- Lee McDonough – Director General of Net Zero, Nuclear and International
- Ben Rimmington – Director General of Net Zero Buildings and Industry
- Professor Paul Monks – DESNZ Chief Scientific Advisor
Jeremy Pocklington
Jeremy Pocklington is the senior civil servant in DESNZ. He graduated from Oxford with a degree in Modern History and later gained a master’s in Economics and Social History. His entire career has been in the Civil Service with spells at the Treasury, the Cabinet Office, DECC and MHCLG. He became the Permanent Secretary in DESNZ in February 2023.
Clive Maxwell
Clive Maxwell graduated from Oxford with a degree in geography in 1992. The experience in his LinkedIn profile does not begin until July 2000, when he became the Head of Environmental and Transport Taxes and Savings Incentives in the Treasury. He then worked his way up in the Treasury before moving to the Office of Fair Trading, where he eventually became the Chief Executive. He subsequently returned to the Civil Service, where he held various senior positions in BEIS and DfT, before becoming the Second Permanent Secretary in DESNZ.
Jonathan Mills
It is not clear what subject Jonathan Mills studied at university, but he is listed as having an MA and MPhil in his biography on the website of De Montford University, so we can be reasonably certain that he is not from a STEM background. Since 2017, he has worked in several senior civil service roles. His career before 2017 is not listed in his biography.
Ashley Ibbett
Ashley Ibbett has been a civil servant for over two decades and has worked in a wide range of roles covering trade, science, innovation, competition and energy. It is not known if he had a career before joining the Civil Service, and his degree subject is not listed.
Lee McDonough
Lee McDonough is a career civil servant with an MBA from Imperial College. She has worked in several departments such as DEFRA, Health, BEIS and is now in charge of Net Zero, Nuclear and International at DESNZ. Her original degree is not listed.
Ben Rimmington
Ben Rimmington is a career civil servant with a degree in modern languages from Cambridge. He joined the Civil Service Fast Stream in 1995 and has worked in the Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, Business Innovation and Skills, Leeds City Enterprise Partnership, DfT and now DESNZ. There is no evidence of commercial experience, and clearly, he has no STEM background.
Professor Paul Monks
Professor Paul Monks graduated from Warwick University with a degree in Chemistry and went on to gain a doctorate in the same subject from Oxford. His career since then has been in research and academia, including a stretch at the NASA Goddard Space Flight Centre where he worked on astrochemistry. He became Chief Scientific Advisor to BEIS in 2020 and to DESNZ in 2023. At last, we have found someone with a STEM background, although in Chemistry with a special interest in astrochemistry. There is no evidence of experience in the commercial world.
David Turver writes the Eigen Values Substack page, where this article first appeared.
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
Interesting. Is there a similar analysis of the vast technical and commercial knowledge the previous government poured into DESNZ?
Similar, I’d guess.
I quite like the idea of “flooding the energy market with cheap renewables and introducing free basic energy”… Let us know when you can do it. Whut? ‘Cheap’ as in ‘subsidised by the state’ and ‘Free’ as in ‘paid for by everyone else’? I thought there would be a catch.
It’s known as the “Fahnbulleh Perpetual Motion Machine”.
Look it up on TikTok. Fascinating stuff.
I hadn’t realised it had been published in the prestigious scientific journals. I
standsit correctedI believe the total difference in STEM background of our executive and the wealth generating sectors of the economy account for the present state of the U.K. and much of the western world. Simple example – ask what powers an EV. The answer will be – electricity. WRONG – chemical energy in a battery pack. Electricity is simply the carrier of the kinetic energy possessed by moving air into the chemical energy of the battery.
I guarantee not a single member of the DESNZ would comprehend the significance of this.
I don’t think there’s any air involved in an EV battery. It’s part of what makes them difficult to control when they overheat – we can’t just smother them to deprive them of air/oxygen and so control the release of energy. The useful flow of electrons (from negative to positive) through the electronics and motors of the vehicle permits certain chemical reactions to proceed inside the battery. If the internal structure of the battery fails, the electrons can flow within the battery leading to an uncontrolled release of the stored chemical energy.
Prof Paul Christensen gives an excellent presentation of the Lithium ion battery technology and its limitations and failure modes at Green Fire Safety Conference in May 2023 in London. It should be mandatory viewing for all the green zealots
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIXTP-TgPEw
Brilliant link. Thank you.
I particularly like the rocket motor effect from the Nissan Leaf battery at about 10min 30sec and following. Go on – put that out.
For those who start watching the vid and start wondering what EVs have to do with fire safety in high rise buildings keep with it because it does make sense. If there’s an EV in the basement car park it could become everyone’s problem… unlikely perhaps but it’s a new risk which is not something building owners like.
…..and for all ferry or tunnel passengers……………….you’re sitting next to a bomb
Well said.
I think I’m safe to say we are doomed as a nation. What a clown show.
…doomed as a planet, you mean?
Just to add that Prof Paul Monks might agree with the truth of my statement but might fail to see the significance
“David Turver casts a critical eye over the new crop of ministers at the Department of Energy and Net Zero, revealing a batch of public sector lifers with no commercial savvy and zero energy know-how.”
Thus it ever was? Add in all the cult followers – the children, pop musicians, actors and political activists.
‘APPG?’
Come on, pack it in. No I am not going to look it up.
Manners dear boy.
I hear it has links to the Ministry of Funny Walks.
All Party Parliamentary Group
https://www.parliament.uk/about/mps-and-lords/members/apg/
Thank you.
Acronyms not previously defined really, really P. me off.
CLIMATE CHANGE —–The gift to Communists that just keeps giving and giving and giving. CO2 is the Progressives dream gas, since all human activity involves the release of some CO2, what better way to control all human activity than controlling that CO2. This is why you can have a degree in Lego or the History of Lapland to work at the Department of Energy and Net Zero because it isn’t and never was about science. It is about implementing the Sustainable Development and Social Justice Goals of Klaus Schwab and Antonia Guterres, and for that your only qualifications are to be an anti capitalist and a traitor to your own country.
I don’t believe for one second that any of these people believes that “net zero” as they say it will happen is actually achievable and I doubt they care. My scientific background stops at O Level and I can see it’s bollocks. This has nothing to do with science and everything to do with politics, specifically socialism.
“My scientific background stops at O Level and I can see it’s bollocks.”
Honoured to share your company tof.
And me. I do, however, have a PhD in Living In The Real World.
I’m not surprised at all, but thank you for diligently working through the data.
My only explanation is that, if you have no STEM knowledge or experience, you can blame the unfolding tragedy on others.
What does appal me is that so few I meet have ANY understanding of Science at all. For example, quoting the BBC appears, for many, to settle the matter.
Talk about revolutionaries capturing the radio and TV stations early on: and they have.
This mirrors other departments and their strategies. Indeed the rot is deep; as not only are the core decision makers scientifically illiterate but they are incapable of choosing competent experts to pick apart their proposals. As a comparison look at the SAGE committee members and decide how many of (the too many) of them have significant clinical experience in acute medicine. When the conclusions of such groups are questioned they shut the door and lock it.
What is required across all government departments is a system that enforces independent scrutiny by proper experts. The Daily Sceptic has shown over the last four years that it is capable of collecting such experts, so perhaps it should formalise links with scientific and medical peers who can raise concerns, objections and the truth in the Upper House, which might be able to block the worst excesses.
Bottom line: if I develop signs of a brain tumour I do not wish to have my care managed by a gynaecologist, no matter how good they are. Which is why, as a parallel thread, the overseeing of the NHS review by a teaching hospital surgeon is a flawed decision, not least because the chosen one has done it before and failed.
No one should be able to enter parliament as an MP or SPAD, without a minimum of 10 years in the commercial sector, or outside of the civil service.
The list above exemplifies the sort of person who now enters politics, career politicians straight out of University, no world experience, no experience of working and living alongside “normal” people, in other words the ones who pay their wages.
Westminster is the ultimate “old pals” club, a bunch of pompous arrogant elites who believe they know better how to tell people to run their lives.
What a mess.
The article omits the fact that every single one of them has a PhD in Bullshit.
A very interesting analysis and one which should be applied to many other government offices.
But I would give Paul Monks his due: gaining a doctorate at Oxford used to mean a lot and he has unique international experience working at NASA’s GSFC. Studying anything astro-wise means he will definitely be a good mathematician but I imagine he will quickly become bored with his highly unscientific colleagues and leave for a more interesting post in a different environment.
Or maybe he will convince his colleagues there is no such thing as global warming?! There is (supposed to be) always hope.
Jonty and Tobias good working class names
It is the department for Energy Security and NZ. So even responsible for two òf our vital interests in the energy sector
Is Milliband as stupid as he looks, or is he acting in the Fabian tradition ?
Brilliant analysis