Keir Starmer’s planned VAT raid on private schools is likely to breach human rights law because it singles out private education for the levy, a senior lawyer has said. The Telegraph has the story.
The Labour leader risks falling foul of European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) law over his party’s flagship policy, one of Britain’s top constitutional and human rights lawyers has warned.
Lord Pannick, who has taken on some of the U.K.’s most high-profile court cases, backed legal advice warning that making private schools subject to VAT was likely to breach ECHR law.
He told the Telegraph: “It would be strongly arguable that for a new government to impose VAT on independent schools would breach the right to education.
“That is because all other educational services will remain exempt from VAT and the charging of VAT on independent schools alone is designed to impede private education, and will have that effect.”
The KC and crossbench peer said that the Labour policy risked breaching two articles in the ECHR which protect the right to education.
He referred to legal advice written in response to Labour policies as far back as the early 1980s, when the country’s most senior lawyers warned that plans to end tax exemptions for private schools or abolish the institutions altogether would likely breach international human rights law to which Britain is signed up.
Seems the Left might be getting entangled in its own anti-democratic ‘human rights’ Blob.
Worth reading in full.
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
Many say he’s a psychopath. I think he’s just a bit thick.
His own blog shows this very clearly. Especially this little article, from 2016:
https://www.gatesnotes.com/development/smells-of-success
Read that and tell me he’s intelligent.
And the fact he hasn’t removed it. No wonder India has banned the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation from operating in India.
Sorry Joe I started reading it and then realised I couldn’t be arsed. I did have a brief flick through his book in Waterstones it was incredibly simplistic and the illustrations were infantile. Not really the type you would want influencing “world health”. The only thing he is interested in is power and wealth and the covid scam (he helped create) has given him the perfect opportunity to increase both. He doesn’t give two flying f**ks about anybodies health.
Oh I couldn’t agree more, Jabba. Just disputing the psychopath assertion.
I owe my career to Microsoft, so I used to respect him, and used to read his blog.
Then, in 2016, reading that article, I woke up.
And then when in February 2020, he resigned completely from Microsoft to “focus on humanitarian efforts”, I was certain about his idiocy and myopia.
I think he got interested in helping ‘those poor Africans’ about 20 years ago, when he realised he had more money than sense. I think this started out as being a ‘give something back’ type interest, but he’s just been overtaken by it. Its well beyond his scope and expertise, and he’s just a dangerous meddler, as you often find in people who are geniuses* in their own field, they seem to imagine that it is magically applicable to every other challenge on the planet.
*I am a survivor of Windows Vista. So ‘genius’ comes with some caveats…
Agreed, possibly not a psychopath but certainly paranoid, demonstrating a textbook example of the Messiah Complex.
And congratulations to India for their common sense. Possibly the result of having hosted too many dodgy fakirs in their time?
“The directing and coordinating authority for health within the United Nations system”.
Yes. Which means their recommendations will tend towards creating an increased role for the UN, the same as with the environment and the climate scare.
As for Billy boy, people like him are a poison in the body of science and health. He is a known eugenicist and using his clout to continue the failed policies of the 1930s by other means and on record as wanting to reduce the world population, and also has a serious conflict of interest with big pharma.
People like the Orthomolecular Medicine News Service should be given more of a say on public health but won’t be, and not for scientific reasons
orthomolecular.org/resources/omns/v16n04.shtml
No, vitamin C and vitamin D won’t turn a nice profit for Billy boy and, shock horror, might prevent governments giving experimental medication emergency authorisation (and liability exemption for big pharma). Hence those rigged vitamin D trials (and the nonsense about ivermectin – except in Uttar Pradesh), and maybe the death of Tanzania’s president and his on-message replacement.
And by the way, what is Paypal doing defunding TDS (See GB News, “Mark Steyn” (hosted by Mark Dolan) show tonight) ? Maybe these twerps should tell us what financial interests they have in the matter?
Be very clear, Paypal can for now be considered enemies of free speech, and should be avoided where possible.
Maybe we should have a story on what some of these tech companies are up to?
NB Paypal have basically said no comment. Let’s hear what these muppets are really up to. Toby has rightly said he will have no more to do with them, and I suggest others follow suit.
I ditched PayPal when they did the same thing to the FLCCC several months ago. This latest thing comes as no surprise and I now wouldn’t touch them with a bargepole.
Very difficult to contact them in order to give them the benefit of your opinion, though.
check the online reviews of PayPal at TrustPilot. 1/5 usually.
That high??
All these global bodies hate ordinary people. Every crisis is being manufactured.
WE need to keep protesting and spreading the message
Yellow Boards By The Road
There are wolves and sheep. We are the sheep dogs.
Thursday 22nd September 11am to 12pm
Yellow Boards
Junction A30 London Rd &
A325 Portsmouth Road
Camberley GU15 3UZ
Friday 23rd September 11am to 12pm
Yellow Boards
Junction Long Hill Road, New Forest Ride &
A329 London Rd (near Mercedes Benz)
Bracknell RG12 9FR
Stand in the Park Sundays 10.30am to 11.30am – make friends & keep sane
Wokingham
Howard Palmer Gardens Sturges Rd RG40 2HD
Bracknell
South Hill Park, Rear Lawn, RG12 7PA
Telegram http://t.me/astandintheparkbracknell
This 2 minute vid sums up the corruption involved in the WHO and how ‘Teddy boy,’ of all people, was appointed its leader;
https://rumble.com/vuqft6-who-is-w.h.o.-.html
I’m not sure why the author assumes that the “global health” racket he describes is based on good intentions.
I have yet to encounter a racket that wasn’t intended primarily to benefit the racketeers.
I knew Bill Gates was a danger to humanity the moment I saw him in early 2020 do the rounds on network television advocating lockdowns.
It’s good to see some momentum gathering against him. He needs to be stopped.
He’s a Chunt but moving on I’ve just watched Tobias 77th Elwood on Mark Dolans GB news talking bollocks about our billions of squid going to Ukraine , he’s well dodgy ! Also any views on the silencing of Alex Belfield for 5,1/2 long years ???…
Re Alex I am truly gutted about it. In the words of Ian Hislop if this is justice then I am a banana.
We need to support Toby and this website
‘Something more sinister is going on’ | Toby Young on Paypal shutting down payments to his websites
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tmDLssmC68
‘This is the new battlefront in the ongoing war against free speech… financial services being withdrawn from people.’ Founder of the Free Speech Union and the Daily Sceptic, Toby Young, speaks to Mark Dolan about his organisations being blocked by Paypal.
GBNews
Hold your head high and don’t let yourself get depressed
Even though the world is getting crazier each day, you can keep sane by doing Yellow Boards By The Road
There are wolves and sheep. We are the sheep dogs.
Thursday 22nd September 11am to 12pm
Yellow Boards
Junction A30 London Rd &
A325 Portsmouth Road
Camberley GU15 3UZ
Friday 23rd September 11am to 12pm
Yellow Boards
Junction Long Hill Road, New Forest Ride &
A329 London Rd (near Mercedes Benz)
Bracknell RG12 9FR
Stand in the Park Sundays 10.30am to 11.30am – make friends & keep sane
Wokingham
Howard Palmer Gardens Sturges Rd RG40 2HD
Bracknell
South Hill Park, Rear Lawn, RG12 7PA
Telegram http://t.me/astandintheparkbracknell
coercive control is characterised by a pretence of ‘helping’ the victim, while simultaneously causing injury to the victim.
Dr David Bell wrote a very good short piece about the state of global public health;
https://www.pandata.org/the-naked-absurdity-of-global-public-health/
I trust Bill Gates rather less than the Chinese Communist Party.
After all, the latter has people who may be evil but are intelligent.
Interesting bit of Gates gossip in this vid – back in 2017 Trump was prompted to investigate vaccine damage. gates advised him ‘that would be a dead end’ *of course*
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CXHT8-pN5H4
advised by no less than RFK Jr
What does evil look like? Bill Gates. He locked up the world to enrich himself and most likely raped young girls on Epstein’s island.
We’re looking at a modern dictator, with the intention of superceding democracy, in effect.
Resident Biden tells us the (Hoax) er, the pandemic is over. His mail in the voting scam is done
It’s utterly frightening that this narcissistic psychotic can wield such power because of the amount of money he has. This is the same man who told us the scamdemic wouldn’t be over until we had vaccinated the world!….
Well Africa seems to have done very well without the ‘magic potion’, and yet they are still insisting on making them take it….money allows coercion of the worst kind..
I have tried but can see nothing but illegitimate power, profit and evil emanating from this man and everything he touches…
“the area of study, research and practice that places a priority on improving health and achieving equity in health for all people worldwide”
I find the work equity when used in relation to healthcare chilling. Having worked in a Cinderella service within the NHS since 1985 I know all too well about the pressure to provide an ‘equitable’ service. Way back in 1990 the demand for community SLT was so high that waiting times were in the order of 6-8 months as the service was grossly underfunded (caseloads carried by each SLT for a full-time post was between 100 – 150). The boss’ solution to this was to have her clinician’s work their sessions from one or two clinics so that they weren’t spending their time travelling when they should have been eating or could have been carrying out clinical work. She identified clinics with an appropriate room (not a cupboard as had been offered – I kid you not), with good bus links & all referrals were offered a choice of clinic. Some refused to travel to the nearest clinic as it was too far away. Their choice. Others complained that they couldn’t be seen locally whilst refusing to travel & the majority opted for the clinic location offered.
The boss put her foot down & gave the management a headache by stating that they had three options: continue with the status quo & provide the best quality service even if it wasn’t the most equitable; provide an equitable but poor quality service whilst running her clinical staff into the ground or they could expand the service to ensure a quality equitable service. She however refused to run with the second option.
Guess what? We had 4 new WTE posts created within 3 months!!!
Equity in healthcare in my experience usually correlates with crap healthcare provision. But hey! Its equitable.