• Login
  • Register
The Daily Sceptic
No Result
View All Result
  • Articles
  • About
  • Archive
    • ARCHIVE
    • NEWS ROUND-UPS
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletter
  • Premium
  • Donate
  • Log In
The Daily Sceptic
No Result
View All Result

Academics Claim There Was a “Non-Binary Minority” in Prehistoric Europe

by Noah Carl
6 June 2023 11:00 AM

Until relatively recently, many people would have assumed the term ‘non-binary’ had something to do with computers. Yet today, by far the most common usage is to refer to people who reject the so-called gender binary, which stipulates that one’s gender identity must be the same as one’s ‘sex assigned at birth’.

According to the 2021 Census, there are at least 30,000 non-binary people in England and Wales. And note: these individuals actually wrote “non-binary” on the census form (unlike some respondents, they didn’t misunderstand the question). But is there really such a thing as non-binary?

Does it reflect a distinct set of psychological tendencies? Or is it just a label people use because they belong to a particular subculture? Many of us would suspect the latter. Indeed, “non-binary” was barely mentioned on Twitter or searched on Google before 2014. 

Mentions of ‘non-binary’ and ‘nonbinary’ over time.

Enter Eleonore Pape and Nicola Ialongo – two academics from Göttingen University in Germany. They recently published a paper in the Cambridge Archaeological Journal which argues that “non-binary minorities were systematically represented in the burial rite of prehistoric Europe”.

The authors’ method was straightforward. They inferred deceased individuals’ sex using osteological analysis, and inferred their ‘gender’ by checking whether they were buried with masculine or feminine grave goods (weapons, for example, were considered masculine). They then looked to see whether their sex and gender matched. And in roughly 10% of cases, it did not.

The authors concede that their method may be subject to error. And they acknowledge “there is no indication at all of whether such a ‘mismatched identity’ was chosen by their bearers or rather imposed on them, either in life or in death”. Yet they do posit the existence of a “non-binary minority” in pre-historic Europe.

As Pape stated in a press release, “we can no longer frame non-binary persons as ‘exceptions’ to a rule, but rather as ‘minorities’, who could have been formally acknowledged, protected and even revered”. Though her co-author clarified, “this is only one possible interpretation”. 

You don’t say! Isn’t the far more reasonable interpretation that people were buried with different objects for all sorts of reasons, and there’s no reason to believe that prehistoric Europeans even distinguished between sex and gender? We in the West have only been doing it for about 10 years.

It’s logically possible, I suppose, that prehistoric Europeans did so. It’s just extremely unlikely. And the mere fact that some men were buried with female-typical objects and some women were buried with male-typical ones shouldn’t really shift our confidence.

If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. And for many academics all they have is gender theory, so the presence of flint blades or arrowheads in a woman’s grave looks like evidence of non-binary gender. The next step, I imagine, will be inferring the gender identity of pre-human hominids.

Tags: AcademiaNon-binaryWoke

Donate

We depend on your donations to keep this site going. Please give what you can.

Donate Today

Comment on this Article

You’ll need to set up an account to comment if you don’t already have one. We ask for a minimum donation of £5 if you'd like to make a comment or post in our Forums.

Sign Up
Previous Post

Lockdown Sceptic Molly Kingsley: “I Was Cast as an Extremist But I’ve Since Been Proved Right”

Next Post

WHO and EU Announce Global System of Vaccine Passports for “Future Pandemics”

Subscribe
Login
Notify of
Please log in to comment

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

35 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
2 years ago

Blimey they are getting desperate – for attention, funding, validation. The whole business is such obvious cobblers that bigger and bigger lies and more ridiculous nonsense is required to stop the vast, moth-eaten brocade from falling apart.

Anyway, who cares? I mean it’s probably made up nonsense but let’s say there were non-binary people back then – well, if we think that kind of thing is an aberration now then we think it was an aberration then. Humans are weird creatures different from other animals and have been for a very long time.

81
-1
RW
RW
2 years ago
Reply to  transmissionofflame

They’re not at all getting desparate. They’ve been churning out ahistorical speculations based on their preconceived view of how things ought to be about all conceivable historical topics for a long time. This has brought me to the point – and that’s seriously extreme for me – of throwing away some history books I bought about topics which interested me, sometimes even only half read, whenever I hit upon another one based on a magpie’s selection of bits and pieces of disparate sources and loads of blathering, eg, Ring of Steel, a fairly new book about the civil situation of the central powers after having been cut off from food imports by the British sea blockade from 1914 – 1919.

This book could be regarded as a teaching example of simulated learnedness applied to obscure things instead of revealing them. A tell-tale sign is when people stay clear of any real historical sources because They just can’t be trusted! in favour of perfectly random eyewitness accounts supposed to appear authentic to our modern taste because they’re so personal.

25
0
Jon Garvey
Jon Garvey
2 years ago

The acid test, I suggest, would be to do the same experiment on European graves from the historic period, when there’s no documentary evidence of non-binaries.

If the pattern were significantly different, it would suggest that transgenderism miraculously disappeared with the appearance of writing until European academics rediscovered it in this century. That would be a remarkable story to explain.

If, more likely, the same phenomenon is observed, then Pope & Iolongo are refuted. What’s the betting they won’t do the experiment to discover the truth!

42
0
soundofreason
soundofreason
2 years ago
Reply to  Jon Garvey

Sorry for the late reply.

I don’t think examining grave goods for European graves from the historic period will be representative. Burying bodies with grave goods has long been discouraged in the Christian traditions. I’ve no doubt it still happened (happens) but it will be more selective and less simply burying the body with the deceased’s ‘tools of the trade’.

Quite why one of my sisters asked that Mum should be buried ‘with a clean tissue in her pocket’ escapes me – but it was certainly not worth risking a rift over.

1
0
RW
RW
2 years ago

Postmodern pseudo-historians absolutely love prehistory. We have no real information about that (that’s why its called prehistory), hence, they don’t even have to justify why they’re ignoring all sources which might exist in favour of their own speculations based lack of knowledge.

This so-called paper is a work of fiction and not of science. And it’s not even coherent: Non-binary is supposed to refer to people who are neither men nor women because they don’t feel like either. That there are two distinguishable styles for burying people, one regarded as stereotypically male and the other as stereotypically female doesn’t even theoretically support this hypothesis. Further, If they seem to have been warriors, they cannot have been women! (and vice-versa) just betrays the misogynistic (and misandristic) prejudices of the authors of this piece political phantasizing.

Last edited 2 years ago by RW
43
0
Mogwai
Mogwai
2 years ago

I agree with you, Noah. I call ”cobblers” on this paper! So you get a female skeleton but because it’s been buried with weapons it was a ”non-binary” person? So women never fought in battles in years gone by? And men never baked or cooked anything either?? Jeez…Well I’m glad the authors acknowledged their conclusions have more holes than a Swiss cheese factory.

As to this whole ”non-binary” business, it’s in vogue and all part of the Woke movement. To my mind non-binary equates to people being either one or a mix of the following; confused, experimental or they have a mental disorder, the latter is in no way meant as an insult as ‘gender dysphoria’ appears to be something else which has blown out of all proportion lately, as I had barely heard of this legit diagnosis a few years back. I think this is just another example of the current obsession with sticking labels on people so that they can be pigeon-holed, as it suits the social engineers that want to pit us against each other, and I don’t think a label necessarily equates to a healthy sense of self. Be self-confident and comfortable in your own skin, shove social conformity and gender ideology and keep your labels for sticking on jars.

50
0
RW
RW
2 years ago
Reply to  Mogwai

Don’t you know that women can’t fight and men cannot cook? Sheesh … one could almost believe you must have partially grown up in the 20th century while such enlightended statements about gender stereotype where temporarily no more en vogue. Thankfully, this has since been fixed by the people who really need them. A man will turn into a woman the very moment he even come close to a cooking pot!

29
-1
Mogwai
Mogwai
2 years ago
Reply to  RW

By their stupid “logic” the chef profession is dominated by non-binary people.🤦‍♀️ Do you wanna tell Gordon Ramsey or shall I?🤣

38
0
Steve-Devon
Steve-Devon
2 years ago
Reply to  RW

Yes indeed this whole issue highlights the incredible rigidity of gender stereotypes that we apply in our world with regard to clothing, appearance, things and activities deemed feminine or masculine. With some of the children’s trans literature I have seen, it talks about; do you feel like a girly girl, typified by Dorothy from the Wizard of Oz or like a rough tough boy, typified by Huckleberry Finn?
The stereotypes and images seem to be counted as more important than the basic fact of male and female in human reproduction.

14
0
FerdIII
FerdIII
2 years ago
Reply to  Mogwai

Indeed. Women fought. Women were warriors, queens, owners of estates, virgins, prostitutes, mendicants, house slaves, free women, high born, low born. There were many disciplines for women.
A woman buried with nothing is still a woman – because she has ovaries and a vagina.
A woman buried with 1000 swords is still a woman – because she has ovaries and a vagina.
A woman buried with a dead cat is still a woman – because she has ovaries and a vagina….

Last edited 2 years ago by FerdIII
57
-1
transmissionofflame
transmissionofflame
2 years ago

Vaguely on topic

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-65809944

England cricketers become first LGBT couple to read CBeebies bedtime story

6
0
soundofreason
soundofreason
2 years ago
Reply to  transmissionofflame

…first LGBT couple to read CBeebies bedtime story

erm… how do we know?

Also:

Are they the first cricketing couple to read on CBeebies bedtime story? (probably)

Are they the first couple to read on CBeebies bedtime story? (quite possibly)

They’ve had many famous people read on that show – some have been much better at it than others. I have grandchildren, so I was allowed to watch it with them.

6
0
RW
RW
2 years ago
Reply to  transmissionofflame

This should trigger an instant set of complaints: Pride is a political adult activity supposed to celebrate some people’s non heterosexual (so-called) sex lifes. That’s not something children below 16 are supposed to be saddled with, no matter how many savilley BBC perverts really want this.

33
0
Dinger64
Dinger64
2 years ago

I can just imagine a hairy arsed caveman dragging his women into the cave by her hair before asking “oh, Sorry, do you identify as a woman?”

16
0
soundofreason
soundofreason
2 years ago
Reply to  Dinger64

In your imagination is the hairy arsed caveman male or female?

More importantly how the hell did that get into my head to the extent that I asked the question?

11
0
Dinger64
Dinger64
2 years ago
Reply to  soundofreason

🤣🤣🤣
All that hair must have been difficult to see though!

Last edited 2 years ago by Dinger64
1
0
Marque1
Marque1
2 years ago
Reply to  Dinger64

It’s only polite so that you know which entrance to use.

6
-1
Dinger64
Dinger64
2 years ago
Reply to  Marque1

And you don’t mean, entrance to the cave do you?🤣

2
0
DomH75
DomH75
2 years ago

Occam’s razor: Academics make shit up! 😀

19
0
Jumpin' Jehosaphat
Jumpin' Jehosaphat
2 years ago

Academics are the stupidest people on Earth. Dangerously stupid.

17
0
NeilofWatford
NeilofWatford
2 years ago

Based on the same models that predicted millions of covid deaths and deadly global warming, no doubt.

13
0
Monro
Monro
2 years ago

I don’t think there could have been ‘non binary’ much before 1945 because sex and gender meant the same thing up to that point, both determined biologically.

‘Sexologist John Money introduced the terminological distinction between biological sex and gender as a role in 1955.

Before his work, it was uncommon to use the word gender to refer to anything but grammatical categories.

However, Money’s meaning of the word did not become widespread until the 1970s, when feminist theory embraced the concept of a distinction between biological sex and the social construct of gender.’

Scholarly Community Encyclopedia

Last edited 2 years ago by Monro
7
0
RW
RW
2 years ago
Reply to  Monro

Thanks for confirming that that’s indeed a notion straight from the 1950, ie, stuff teenage babyboomers absorbed in ther youth (who would then become academic feminists in the 1970s and rules of the world shortly after 2000). Isn’t it great when a supposedly modern society must suddenly be catapulted backwards by almost 50 years because of stuff so-called middle-aged people learned in their youth and aren’t willing to let go off despite times have moved on? That’s soo progressive!

7
-1
Monro
Monro
2 years ago
Reply to  RW

‘….the “Dialectical Left,” which includes Communism, achieves its agendas most effectively by strategically changing the meanings of words.’

‘…there are just three terms that have been profoundly subverted and are being used to transform our society by Communists for Communist ends. These are inclusion, democracy, and citizenship.’

‘Three Terms Communists Redefined to Subvert Society’ James Lindsay Sept 2022

I suspect the change in meaning of ‘gender’ has come about from a well left of centre agenda.

Quite how it helps implement that agenda is not clear since it has opened up a clear divide between different sectors of the ‘Dialectical Left’, much to the amusement of many…..

Last edited 2 years ago by Monro
1
0
Marque1
Marque1
2 years ago

An University of Pittsburgh classroom erupted with laughter after a Professor argued with swimmer Riley Gaines that an archaeologist cannot discern whether a person was male or female by examining their bones. He complained, after laughter subsided that he had a PHD and should know what he was talking about.
So, how did these two tell from ostelogical analysis the sex or gender of the skeletons if it can’t be done? Is there, perchance, a possibility that someone is telling porkies? Perhaps they need to get their ducks all in a row behind one fib theory/fact. I am only a simple soul and am easily confused by clever people so I would really appreciate it.

11
0
DevonBlueBoy
DevonBlueBoy
2 years ago
Reply to  Marque1

The very obvious way of distinguishing male and female skeletons is by the differences between their pelvic girdles. Common sense 101.
And as IVF wasn’t invented back then, just how did these non binaries procreate?

4
0
jburns75
jburns75
2 years ago

I carry a broadsword around with me in case people mistake me for a woman.

Last edited 2 years ago by jburns75
19
0
Dinger64
Dinger64
2 years ago
Reply to  jburns75

Would you be that easy to mistake for a woman? 😁

3
0
RW
RW
2 years ago
Reply to  Dinger64

You can never really know the gender of a bearded guy who isn’t carrying a large edged weapon!

10
0
DevonBlueBoy
DevonBlueBoy
2 years ago
Reply to  jburns75

🤣🤣🤣

0
0
For a fist full of roubles
For a fist full of roubles
2 years ago

It is quite amazing that the tendency survives. Presumably it is not genetic otherwise I would expect it to disappear in one generation.

3
0
RTSC
RTSC
2 years ago

I wonder how much they were paid, and by whom/what, to come up with their flight of fancy?

3
0
nige.oldfart
nige.oldfart
2 years ago

The modern trait of academics looking at history through a twenty first century viewpoint only confirms their ignorance, as all things, as in science should be conducted objectively not subjectively. Historically cooking pots were a measure of wealth, and ownership did not infer whether the owner was a man or a woman, just wealth.

2
0
RW
RW
2 years ago
Reply to  nige.oldfart

These people are not historians. They’re defense archeologists looking for something ancient (prehistory strongly preferred) which can be interpreted such that it seems to support a preexisting theory of them.

2
0
Matt Mounsey
Matt Mounsey
2 years ago

There was no such thing as straight or gay until around 150 years ago in Western civilisation.

David Benkoff’s article in Daily Caller from 2014 is a great summary of the anthropology:

Nobody is ‘born that way,’ gay historians say | The Daily Caller

How we’ve gotten to this level of confusion is something future historians will mock us mercilessly for.

0
0

NEWSLETTER

View today’s newsletter

To receive our latest news in the form of a daily email, enter your details here:

DONATE

PODCAST

The Sceptic | Episode 45: Jack Hadfield on the Anti-Asylum Protests, Alan Miller on the Tyranny of Digital ID and James Graham on the Net Zero Pension Threat

by Richard Eldred
25 July 2025
0

LISTED ARTICLES

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Editor’s Picks

The False Promises of Electric Vehicles Are Being Exposed

29 July 2025
by Tilak Doshi

News Round-Up

29 July 2025
by Richard Eldred

Leaked Email Blows Apart BBC’s Impartiality Claims Over Gaza

29 July 2025
by Will Jones

Is the Tide Turning Against Woke Comedy?

29 July 2025
by C.J. Strachan

Town Councillor Who Asked Questions About 300 Migrants in a Hotel is “Reported to Police” for “Stirring Up Racial Hatred”

28 July 2025
by Will Jones

The False Promises of Electric Vehicles Are Being Exposed

34

News Round-Up

30

Starmer to Recognise a Palestinian State

26

Farage Demands Apology After Labour Minister Says He is on the Side of Predators like Jimmy Savile for Wanting to Scrap Online Safety Act Over Free Speech Concerns

24

Is the Tide Turning Against Woke Comedy?

19

The NHS ‘Non-Jobs’ Bonanza

29 July 2025
by David Craig

Is the Tide Turning Against Woke Comedy?

29 July 2025
by C.J. Strachan

The Claim that the Epping Protest is Really a ‘Nazi Pogrom’ is a Classic Left-Wing Conspiracy Theory

29 July 2025
by Steven Tucker

The False Promises of Electric Vehicles Are Being Exposed

29 July 2025
by Tilak Doshi

Something Fishy in Grimsby: A Museum Caught in the Woke Net

28 July 2025
by Jack Watson

POSTS BY DATE

June 2023
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« May   Jul »

SOCIAL LINKS

Free Speech Union

NEWSLETTER

View today’s newsletter

To receive our latest news in the form of a daily email, enter your details here:

POSTS BY DATE

June 2023
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« May   Jul »

DONATE

LISTED ARTICLES

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Editor’s Picks

The False Promises of Electric Vehicles Are Being Exposed

29 July 2025
by Tilak Doshi

News Round-Up

29 July 2025
by Richard Eldred

Leaked Email Blows Apart BBC’s Impartiality Claims Over Gaza

29 July 2025
by Will Jones

Is the Tide Turning Against Woke Comedy?

29 July 2025
by C.J. Strachan

Town Councillor Who Asked Questions About 300 Migrants in a Hotel is “Reported to Police” for “Stirring Up Racial Hatred”

28 July 2025
by Will Jones

The False Promises of Electric Vehicles Are Being Exposed

34

News Round-Up

30

Starmer to Recognise a Palestinian State

26

Farage Demands Apology After Labour Minister Says He is on the Side of Predators like Jimmy Savile for Wanting to Scrap Online Safety Act Over Free Speech Concerns

24

Is the Tide Turning Against Woke Comedy?

19

The NHS ‘Non-Jobs’ Bonanza

29 July 2025
by David Craig

Is the Tide Turning Against Woke Comedy?

29 July 2025
by C.J. Strachan

The Claim that the Epping Protest is Really a ‘Nazi Pogrom’ is a Classic Left-Wing Conspiracy Theory

29 July 2025
by Steven Tucker

The False Promises of Electric Vehicles Are Being Exposed

29 July 2025
by Tilak Doshi

Something Fishy in Grimsby: A Museum Caught in the Woke Net

28 July 2025
by Jack Watson

SOCIAL LINKS

Free Speech Union
  • Home
  • About us
  • Donate
  • Privacy Policy

Facebook

  • X

Instagram

RSS

Subscribe to our newsletter

© Skeptics Ltd.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Articles
  • About
  • Archive
    • ARCHIVE
    • NEWS ROUND-UPS
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletter
  • Premium
  • Donate
  • Log In

© Skeptics Ltd.

wpDiscuz
You are going to send email to

Move Comment
Perfecty
Do you wish to receive notifications of new articles?
Notifications preferences